The McKinsey Quarterly · 1993 · 24 citations · 0 references
BusinessStrategic ManagementStrategyBusiness StrategyCorporate StrategyStrategic PlanningBusiness Growth StrategiesInternational ExpansionInvestmentOrganizational StrategyTransnational CorporationsOperating Profitability
As regional growth blossoms, past approaches to strategic and organizational success may no longer be adequate SOME OF THE WORLD'S most profitable and fastest-growing business groups are based in East and Southeast Asia's newly industrialized and emerging economies -- Hong Kong, Singapore, Korea, Taiwan, China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, and the Philippines. Several, such as Indonesia's Salim Group and the Hong Kong-focused Swire and Jardine groups, have reached a size that would rank them among the Fortune 500; others, such as Sime Darby from Malaysia, are moving close. Even though a few have faltered in recent years, the majority have profitability levels outstripping those of many companies in the United States, Europe, and Japan. They also have healthy balance sheets and cashflow, and are capable of financing much of their own expansion. The strategies and organizational approaches that have made these groups so successful in the past, however, will not necessarily serve them well in the future, as they pursue further growth and diversification. They are entering an era of more open and demanding Asian markets -- an era that will severely test their established business formulas. Some groups have the potential -- certainly, most have the resources -- to reshape themselves for this new environment, so that they can continue to dominate their home markets and, perhaps, become leading regional or even international players. Those that fail to do so will stall abruptly as customer, competitor, and regulatory changes sweep the region. Patterns of success Each of Asia's economies has a handful of leading companies, most of which are closely held and influenced by their founding families. Indonesia's Salim Group is guided by the Liem family, for example; Taiwan's Far Eastern Group by the Hsu family; Thailand's Charoen Pokphand Group by the Chearavanont family. Despite their size, these companies remain, for the most part, entrepreneurial and agile, willing to experiment with new business opportunities and to seek first-mover or early-mover advantages as new industries and markets open up. Most have built their wealth by establishing dominant positions in their home markets, although some have expanded regionally and internationally in recent years. Many are in industries that require relatively low technical skills -- property, local distribution, trading, and retail, for example. Those in more advanced manufacturing or service sectors often rely on foreign technology and expatriate management. A few see themselves as management and investment companies, not tied to specific products but able to identify opportunities and assemble the finance, technology, and skills needed to exploit them. All these companies benefit from operating in the world's fastest-growing region, but they have taken advantage of this opportunity in two very different ways: by influencing the structure of the industries in which they operate in order to create privileged franchises, or by building superior skills and creating value in established business units. The Philippines' Cojuangco Group, for example, has been enormously successful in influencing or leveraging industry structure and regulation in its home markets. By contrast, Sun Hung Kai Properties of Hong Kong appears to have created most of its value from managing its businesses well in a competitive local environment. We call the former structurers and the latter builders. No group is exclusively a structurer or a builder; rather, each is some combination and balance of the two. The Cheung Kong Group, for example, has achieved a combination of favorable industry structure and substantial skills in key businesses (notably in property). However, this classification helps to explain the relative competitive advantages of different Asian groups. Structurers have succeeded largely because of their ability to secure or create business franchises where competition is low. …