The Environmental Costs of Agricultural Trade Liberalization: Mexico-U.S. Maize Trade Under NAFTA

Alejandro Nadal, Timothy A. Wise

2004 · 36 citations · 10 references

Concepts

Abstract

The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) had a profound impact on maize trade between the United States and Mexico. Negotiated tariff reductions and the Mexican government’s decision not to charge some tariffs to which it was entitled resulted in a tripling of US exports to Mexico. This paper examines the environmental implications of this change on both sides of the border, summarizing previous research on the subject and, in the case of Mexico, contributing new data on the key question of the links between NAFTA, poverty, migration, and genetic diversity. For the US, increased exports to Mexico due to trade liberalization represent 1.3% of total US production and should therefore be considered responsible for 1.3% of the environmental impacts of corn production. These are considerable, including: high chemical use; water pollution due to runoff; unsustainable water use for irrigation; the expansion of genetically modified corn; soil erosion; and biodiversity loss. Trends in these areas are presented. For Mexico, the principal potential environmental impact of the loss of a significant share of its domestic maize market to the US is the threat to agro-biodiversity. Preliminary evidence is presented on the extent to which imports and declining prices are reducing the capacity to producte native corn varieties. These changes are placed within an analytical framework that recognizes the possibility that the flow of environmentally unsustainable economic activity in the case of increasing agricultural trade could be the reverse of that assumed in the standard pollution haven scenario, with net environmental costs for the trading partners as a group. We also locate this market-based competition within an analysis of the positive and negative environmental externalities associated with Mexican and US production methods respectively. The result in the liberalized North American market is competition that exacerbates the economic and environmental impacts of those distorted markets. Market failures in one area – negative externalities in the US – interact with market failures in another – positive externalities in Mexico – to create a net environmental impact that is greater than the sum of its parts – the globalization of market failure. We conclude with an analysis of the extent to which this framework can be useful in the analysis of other crops, other countries, and other trade agreements.

References

10