The Gender Citation Gap in International Relations

Daniel Maliniak, Ryan Powers, Barbara F. Walter

International Organization · 2013 · 757 citations · 35 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The study investigates how citation and publication patterns differ between men and women in international relations and examines the impact of author gender on citation network centrality. Using data from the Teaching, Research, and International Policy project on peer‑reviewed publications from 1980 to 2006, the authors analyze citation patterns while controlling for variables such as year, venue, focus, theory, methodology, tenure, and affiliation. Women are systematically cited less and their articles are less central in citation networks; these results are robust to modeling choices and likely stem from women citing themselves less and men citing men more, marking the first political‑science study to reveal significant gender differences in citation patterns.

Abstract

Abstract This article investigates the extent to which citation and publication patterns differ between men and women in the international relations (IR) literature. Using data from the Teaching, Research, and International Policy project on peer-reviewed publications between 1980 and 2006, we show that women are systematically cited less than men after controlling for a large number of variables including year of publication, venue of publication, substantive focus, theoretical perspective, methodology, tenure status, and institutional affiliation. These results are robust to a variety of modeling choices. We then turn to network analysis to investigate the extent to which the gender of an article's author affects that article's relative centrality in the network of citations between papers in our sample. Articles authored by women are systematically less central than articles authored by men, all else equal. This is likely because (1) women tend to cite themselves less than men, and (2) men (who make up a disproportionate share of IR scholars) tend to cite men more than women. This is the first study in political science to reveal significant gender differences in citation patterns and is especially meaningful because citation counts are increasingly used as a key measure of research's quality and impact.

References

35