PLoS ONE · 2013 · 320 citations · 61 references
Life SciencesEvolutionary BiologyZoologyAnimal BehaviorComparative LinguisticsHuman EvolutionAnimal CommunicationBehavioral EvolutionComparative CognitionMammalian CommunicationSocial CommunicationSpeech ActsAlarm CallsGestural CommunicationLanguage EvolutionLanguage OriginsPrimate BehaviorPrimate Behavioral EvolutionPrimate PhylogeneticsPrimate Vocal Communication
The intentionality of primate communication, particularly vocal signals, is essential for understanding language evolution, yet evidence for intentional vocalization in great apes has been lacking. Wild chimpanzees produced two alarm call types that were socially directed, visually monitored, and goal‑directed, indicating intentional vocal signals comparable to gestures and supporting a multimodal origin of human language.
Determining the intentionality of primate communication is critical to understanding the evolution of human language. Although intentional signalling has been claimed for some great ape gestural signals, comparable evidence is currently lacking for their vocal signals. We presented wild chimpanzees with a python model and found that two of three alarm call types exhibited characteristics previously used to argue for intentionality in gestural communication. These alarm calls were: (i) socially directed and given to the arrival of friends, (ii) associated with visual monitoring of the audience and gaze alternations, and (iii) goal directed, as calling only stopped when recipients were safe from the predator. Our results demonstrate that certain vocalisations of our closest living relatives qualify as intentional signals, in a directly comparable way to many great ape gestures. We conclude that our results undermine a central argument of gestural theories of language evolution and instead support a multimodal origin of human language.
61
Kenneth P. Burnham, David R. Anderson · Sociological Methods & Research · 2004 · 11.6K citations
H. P. Grice · The Philosophical Review · 1957 · 2.7K citations
Origins of human communication
Choice Reviews Online · 2009 · 2.2K citations