Agency and Constraint, Perceptions and Practices. A Theoretical Position

Nadja Long

Socio-Environmental Systems Modeling · 1997 · 49 citations · 0 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

role of human agency -the principal protagonists of these struggles are depicted as macro-actors in the form of state systems and transnational corporations.Such macro formulations narrow the focus to privilege analytically the politico-economic institutional structures of agro-food systems, rather than starting from the problematic of producing, making a living, consuming, and maintaining and transforming networks of social relations and cultural identities, both within and beyond the countryside.That is, we must address the problems of how, in differing historical and cultural contexts, rural development interventions and livelihoods are materialized and socially constructed through the interplay, contestation and negotiation of values and interests within specific domains and arenas of social action.Fundamental to this is the view that rural development is composed of a complex series of interlocking practices that are forged through the encounters, struggles and negotiations of different social actors -local farmers, traders, government officials and front-line workers, transnational company managers, politicians, agricultural scientists, and others, who people the networks and normative orders of particular regimes of accumulation and modes of regulation.Each actor (individual or collective) commands different types and scales of resources, interests, values and institutional capacities.Hence the field of rural development is constituted of social meanings and practices that are negotiated in the encounters that take place.Such practices and their outcomes are not predetermined by local cultural, ecological or organizational endowments, nor by wider economic, political, and institutional forces.Rural development is, then, a heterogeneous process involving multiple levels, values and 'realities' -ranging from diverse local patterns of organization and management of resources, to regional economic, political and cultural phenomena, intervening state and non-state institutions, development programmes and representations, and global market, political and cultural scenarios.At the core lie central issues concerning livelihoods, organizational capacities and discourses, and intervention practice and ideology.In short, it is a complex drama about human needs and desires, organizing capabilities, power relations, skills and knowledge, authoritative discourses and institutions, and the clash of different ways of ordering and transforming the world.The challenge of this perspective on rural development is to develop a methodology and analytical framework 2 that allows us to elucidate and analyse the construction of these complex discursive and social forms.A major focus of my own work since the early 1980s has been concerned with developing an actor-oriented framework for looking at these complexities.This chapter continues this task, first, by laying out in summary points the main features of the approach; second, by discussing a number of analytical concepts and issues that require further elucidation and clarification; and finally, by providing a brief account of two types of