D-Scholarship@Pitt (University of Pittsburgh) · 2009 · 10 citations · 40 references
Open access
Social SciencesBehavioral SciencesPsychologyCognitive PsychologyMetacognitionPsychophysiologyEye Movement AnalysisInsight AssessmentInsight Problem SolvingMetacognitive MonitoringProblem SolvingProblem-solving StrategiesAha InsightInsight MeasurementMetacognitive InsightMonitoring During Problem SolvingPupillary FunctionPupillary Response Dynamics
Inspired by the design of Metcalfe and Wiebe (1987), this study is a quest for more fine-grained measures of the differences between insight problem solving and non-insight problem solving at the moment of an 'Aha!'. We avoided asking for metacognitive reports that have been shown to disturb insight problem solving (Schooler, Olsson, & Brooks, 1993), and made use of routine (non-insight) problems of a very similar task nature to compare with the performance, eye-related physiological measures, and subjective ratings of participants on their solving of puzzle (insight) problems. We found that puzzle problems and routine problems led to different pupillary dilations with perception of the tasks and mood as possible mediators of the effect. Profiles of pupillary responses and blinks are found to be indicators that depict characteristics of the task nature when a person is unable to predict his/her own problem solving performance on an insight problem. We also found that discontinuity and restructuring are possibly more important in characterizing an insight problem solving event. Third, instead of the traditional sharp and abrupt but indistinct characterization of the insight moment, our data suggested that an insight is possibly an emerging moment of a sense of clarity about the solution which takes time before the time of an 'Aha!' solution declaration, which converges with some of the claims made according to records of historical scientific discoveries (Gruber, 1995).
40
An argument for basic emotions
Paul Ekman · Cognition & Emotion · 1992 · 9.4K citations
Howard E. Egeth, Daniel Kahneman · The American Journal of Psychology · 1975 · 7.1K citations
Structure‐Mapping: A Theoretical Framework for Analogy*
Dedre Gentner · Cognitive Science · 1983 · 5.1K citations
Schema induction and analogical transfer
Mary L. Gick, Keith J. Holyoak · Cognitive Psychology · 1983 · 2.9K citations · Full text