ASSET REDEPLOYMENT, ACQUISITIONS AND CORPORATE STRATEGY IN DECLINING INDUSTRIES

Jaideep Anand, Harbir Singh

Strategic Management Journal · 1997 · 441 citations · 39 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The resource‑based view posits that firms possess fungible assets that can be redeployed to new markets when existing businesses decline, yet business‑specific routines and managerial skills pose risks to such transformation, leading firms to consider diversification‑oriented or consolidation‑oriented acquisitions. The study investigates performance differences between diversification‑oriented and consolidation‑oriented acquisitions in declining defense industries. The authors compare ex ante and ex post performance outcomes of the two acquisition strategies in these industries. Consolidation‑oriented acquisitions outperform diversification‑oriented ones in the decline phase, yielding higher ex ante and ex post performance and a positive focus–Tobin's q relationship, suggesting that market‑based redeployment of assets is more effective. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Abstract

U.S.A. The resource-based perspective suggests that firms are bundles of assets, some of which are fungible in nature. To the extent that some resources are fungible, firms should be able to redeploy them to enter new markets when their existing businesses decline. On the other hand, perspectives that emphasize the business-specific nature of routines or managerial skills point to inherent risks in organizational transformation. In a declining market, resources can be redeployed within the firm through diversification-oriented acquisitions, or they can be redeployed through market mechanisms through consolidation-oriented acquisitions. In this paper, we examine the differences in performance outcomes between diversification-oriented acquisitions and consolidation-oriented acquisitions in industries within the defense sector, which have experienced significant decline. Our results indicate that consolidation-oriented acquisitions outperform diversification-oriented acquisitions in the decline phase of their industries in terms of both ex ante (stock market based) and ex post (operating) performance measures. At the corporate level, we find a positive relationship between focus and Tobin's q, even when the industry is in decline. The implication of our results is that assets from declining industries are redeployed more effectively through market mechanisms than within the firm through the acquisition of complementary assets. ?1997 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

References

39