Spaces of violence, places of fear: Urban conflict in post-apartheid South Africa

Bronwyn Harris

2003 · 18 citations · 5 references

Concepts

Abstract

Bronwyn Harris is a former Project Manager at the Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation. It is perhaps a cliche to suggest that the more things change, the more they stay the same. But, nine years after South Africa's first democratic elections, we still hear of racial polarization and hatred within communities. Inequality, poverty and access to justice remain key obstacles to establishing a human rights culture. High levels of continue to mark the society; and mistrust, suspicion and fear define many inter-personal relationships. Contrary to the popular representation of South Africa as a miracle nation, high levels of testify that a post-apartheid South Africa is not conflict-free. The more things stay the same, however, the more they also change. This is evident in the many positive changes that separate the new South Africa from the old: the criminalization of racism, an internationally acclaimed Constitution, and systems and institutions that protect and promote human rights. But, alongside these positives, new forms of conflict and prejudice have also emerged, for example, xenophobic hostility towards foreigners, extra- legal vigilante actions of crime fighting, and socio-economic struggles around issues of land and services. Social explanations, understandings and engagement with issues of have also changed with South Africa's transition. In the past, was largely framed as political, both on the part of the apartheid state and through resistance to it. By contrast, today is commonly (and simplistically) labelled criminal (cf. Simpson, 2001). Such a discursive shift has redefined not only but issues of crime, legitimacy and justice. In the process, it has criminalised certain forms of but has simultaneously opened a space for - and legitimised - new violent actions (for example crime fighting). These new trends and explanations of conflict, together with the persistence of old patterns of violence, threaten South Africa's fragile democracy. They challenge the notion that legislated change and a human rights framework will automatically bring an end to within an already violent, militarised society. The persistence of within South Africa also highlights what has been termed a of violence within the country (cf. Simpson, Mokwena & Segal, 1992; Hamber, 1998). Such a culture, wherein is upheld as the primary solution to daily problems and challenges, necessitates the introduction of individual identity and group norms, as well as structural and material factors, into an understanding of during political transition. This paper explores South Africa's culture of violence; it engages with trends, patterns and expressions of conflict in the post-apartheid nation. Drawing on research conducted by the

References

5