Digital Commons - East Tennessee State University (East Tennessee State University) · 2002 · 27 citations · 7 references
EducationCounselingCounselor EducationChildren's RightsEthical Issues In CounselingLegal Issues In CounselingChild RightsParent InvolvementParental ResponsibilityParental RightsStudent RightsConfidentialityConfidentiality DilemmasConfidentiality In MinorsConfidentiality NormsEthical Dilemmas In ConfidentialityParent Rights InParental Rights In EducationParental Rights Limitations
Research indicates that counselors struggle when faced with issues surrounding confidentiality rights of minors and rights of parents. Davis and Mickelson (1994) reported that, in responses to vignettes of legal and ethical dilemmas, school counselors were most confused when dealing with legal issues surrounding parents' rights and students' rights. Similar research by Isaacs and Stone (1999) indicated that there is still considerable variance in school counselors' perceptions of when confidentiality should be breached, particularly in situations where no clear legal or ethical precedent has been established. Such situations can be quite vexing, especially when they carry the potential for significant consequences for students. Although issues surrounding the confidentiality rights of minors have been discussed extensively (Gustafson & McNamara, 1987; Isaacs & Stone, 1999; Kaczmarek, 2000; Ledyard, 1998; Myers, 1982; Sealander, Schwiebert, Oren, & Weekley, 1999; Welfel, 2002), specific guidance for responding to parental demands for confidential information is limited. Difficulties in balancing parental and student rights arise because the confidentiality rights of minor children are not always clearly delineated by law, ethical codes, or social standards (Isaacs & Stone; Ledyard). This lack of clarity may result in school counselors feeling as if they are walking a tightrope between being a professional helper and being an informant to parents. When faced with confidentiality dilemmas that involve minor children, school counselors must take into consideration a number of factors. Central to confidentiality decisions is consideration of the legal and ethical guidelines related to parents' and minors' rights, competency or developmental age of the child, and the best interest of the child (Gustafson & McNamara; Isaacs & Stone). This article focuses on issues surrounding parental rights and the confidentiality rights of minors. Primary legal and ethical considerations with respect to confidentiality of minors are reviewed, arguments central to confidentiality issues are presented, and alternatives available to school counselors when parents demand to know what a child has revealed in a counseling session are provided. CONFIDENTIALITY RIGHTS OF MINORS As is commonly understood, the ethical codes and the law are in agreement that confidentiality is to be broken in cases where child abuse is suspected, in cases of harm to self such as attempted suicide, and in cases where clear and imminent danger to others is threatened. Beyond these three primary instances where confidentiality must be broken, there is ambiguity relative to who has the right to information provided by minors in counseling sessions. Conflicts arise with regards to information shared in counseling sessions because, historically, parents or legal guardians control the legal rights of their children, while the ethical codes extend confidentiality to all clients (Lawrence & Kurpius, 2000). However, neither the law nor the ethical codes provide specific and consistent guidance as to what school counselors should do in all situations where considerations of breaches of confidentiality are relevant. This lack of clarity is further complicated for school counselors because open communication norms are common within school settings among educators, and this practice conflicts with the confidentiality norms of counselors (Welfel, 2002). A brief review of the legal considerations is addressed first, followed by a discussion of the ethical considerations. Minors' Confidentiality Rights and the Law In most areas, the law has not extended confidentiality rights to children. This position is based on historical precedent and issues of competency. Historically, children have moved from a position where parents have absolute power over their lives to the degree that they could be sold into slavery, to their current status where a host of laws have been enacted to protect their rights and well-being (Lawrence & Kurpius, 2000). …
7