Where Should Students with Disabilities Receive Special Education Services?

Naomi Zigmond

The Journal of Special Education · 2003 · 191 citations · 31 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The question of where special education students should be educated is not new. The author reviews existing research on placement and urges new approaches to research and planning to improve outcomes for students with disabilities. The study reviews research studies and reviews that address placement questions. Evidence on placement efficacy is scarce, flawed, and inconclusive, and the question of where to educate students is inappropriate, undermining individualized planning.

Abstract

The question of where special education students should be educated is not new. In this article, the author reviews research studies and research reviews that address this question. She argues that research evidence on the relative efficacy of one special education placement over another is scarce, methodologically flawed, and inconclusive. She also states that “Where should students with disabilities be educated?” is the wrong question to ask, that it is antithetical to the kind of individualized planning that should be embodied in decision making for and with students with disabilities, and that it fails to specify where, for what, and for whom. The author calls for new ways of thinking about the problem and of conducting research so that progress can be made on improving results for students with disabilities.

References

31