eScholarship (California Digital Library) · 2005 · 29 citations · 8 references
Open access
Language StudiesEnglishLinguisticsLanguage AcquisitionPragmaticsPsycholinguisticsArgumentationCounterfactual AnalysisCounterfactual ReasoningDeductive ReasoningPragmatic InferenceSecond Language AcquisitionAssertions
We review the controversy concerning whether the lack of a clear counterfactual marker in Chinese results in a deficiency in counterfactual reasoning (Au, 1983(Au, , 1984;;Bloom, 1981Bloom, , 1984;;Liu, 1985).We describe a study in which we compared two kinds of counterfactual assertions.The results showed an accuracy advantage for English speakers over Chinese speakers when specific contextual information was required to detect the counterfactual, but not on other counterfactual sentences.Implications for language and thought are discussed.
8
Reasoning with contrary-to-fact propositions
Henry Markovits, Robert Vachon · Journal of Experimental Child Psychology · 1989 · 139 citations
Education, Philosophy, Logic +8
Reasoning counterfactually in Chinese: Are there any obstacles?
Lisa Garbern Liu · Cognition · 1985 · 117 citations