Progress in Human Geography · 2001 · 346 citations · 49 references
Social SciencesGeographyPublic PolicyEconomic GeographyPolicy AnalysisSocial GeographyPlace-based PolicyPublic Policy ResponsesPerceptionPolitical CommitmentPublic Policy Debate
Over the past two decades, public policy has been rethought, offering geographers a chance to influence it, yet geography’s impact remains limited as other disciplines dominate policy discussions. The article investigates why geography has limited policy influence and advocates a new policy turn toward a geography of public policy. The authors attribute geography’s limited policy relevance to postmodern and cultural turns, a focus on abstract theory over empirical work, bias against policy studies, and weak political commitment. The study finds that contemporary social and economic geography research is largely irrelevant to policy and, in some cases, to society.
The past two decades have seen a wholesale rethinking and reworking of public policy, and have provided geographers with a major opportunity to enter and help shape the policy debate. Yet, disappointingly, the impact of geography on the policy realm has been limited. Increasingly, it seems, other social, political and environmental scientists, and even media pundits, shape public perception and government policy in areas where we as geographers could – indeed should – be having much greater influence. In this article I examine the reasons for this state of affairs. The fundamental problem, I argue, is that for a variety of reasons much contemporary social and economic geography research renders it of little practical relevance for policy, in some cases of little social relevance at all. The more significant reasons for this lack of relevance to, and influence on, the policy realm include: the effects on the subject of the postmodern and cultural ‘turns’; the consequential emphasis on ‘sexy’ philosophical, linguistic and theoretical issues rather than on practical social research; the retreat from detailed, rigorous empirical work; the intellectual bias against policy studies; and the lack of political commitment. The article makes a plea for a new ‘policy turn’ in the discipline, and concludes with some tentative suggestions for how we might move towards a ‘geography of public policy’.
49
The Competitive Advantage of Nations
Terry Clark, Michael Porter · Journal of Marketing · 1991 · 17.7K citations
The Spatial Economy: Cities, Regions, and International Trade
Thomas J. Holmes, Masahisa Fujita, Paúl Krugman et al. · Southern Economic Journal · 2000 · 5.1K citations
Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference
Kent Mathewson, David Harvey · Geographical Review · 1997 · 4.7K citations
The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy
Richard N. Cooper, Anthony Giddens · Foreign Affairs · 1999 · 3.2K citations