2004 · 12 citations · 5 references
Open access
Social SciencesBusiness EconomicsEconomicsEnergy EconomicsEnergy PolicyIndustrial OrganizationEnergy PoliticsIndustrial PolicyIndustrializationStartup FormationState AidWind Turbine TechnologyEnergy Market ReformMarket Intervention PoliciesOil IndustryState-led GrowthState-led IndustrializationWind Energy Policy
In some situations a strong case can be made for state intervention into the process of industry formation, the so-called baby industry argument. The formation of the wind turbine industry in both the US and Denmark represents case where national governments decided to help in the formation of the wind turbine industry. The form of intervention is crucial to the outcome. Two forms of intervention and their results are analysed in this pa-per. The bottom-up, market-driven approach in Denmark is compared to a top- down, research and development ori-ented approach in the US. The analysis clearly underlines the supremacy of the bottom-up, market-driven form of inter-vention. The present paper unveils the historic development of the wind turbine industry in the United States and Denmark re-spectively and contrasts the two experiences, which has lead to two very different outcomes. In the US, the technologi-cal development basically resulted in nothing more than a shaky industry and 5,000 pages of research results. In Den-mark, however, the development resulted in the formation of several strong companies and the development of an indus-trial cluster, which today accounts for almost 50 % of a US $ 4.5 billion global wind turbine market.
5
The Competitive Advantage of Nations
Terry Clark, Michael Porter · Journal of Marketing · 1991 · 17.7K citations
Wind energy — Clean power for generations
Bourillon · Renewable Energy · 1999 · 11 citations