2006 · 11 citations · 6 references
Public AffairsEducation PolicyPublic PolicyCivil RightsEducation ReformState Education PolicyAccountabilityPolitical AccountabilityRace In SchoolingState AccountabilityAccountability Systems In EducationAdministrative DistrictsParticipation Rate AnalysisQuantitative Data CollectionRacial Equity In EducationSanctionsSchool Accountability SystemsSchool Improvement Districts
This study examines the implications of a shift in accountability under the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) from the school level to the district level. Most states are identifying school districts for sanctioning for the first time during the 2004-2005 school year. Large numbers of districts have been labeled under-performing, and these districts face potentially severe sanctions in the years to come. The heightened importance of district accountability means that it is important to examine both the efficacy of NCLB’s method for identifying districts for sanctioning it effect on the low-income and minority students. We studied NCLB district accountability in six states – Arizona, California, Georgia, Illinois, New York, and Virginia – that are part of the Civil Rights Project’s ongoing research on NCLB. Qualitative and quantitative data from these states allowed us to examine the implementation of district level accountability in unique political, demographic, and geographic contexts. Our analysis is presented in three parts. First, we report descriptive data from our six states to determine the characteristics of the districts identified for improvement. Next, we examine how the NCLB subgroup rules, mean proficiency, and the participation rate requirements affect the likelihood that a district will fail to make adequate yearly progress. Third, we examine the efficacy of negotiated agreements with the U.S. Department of Education that allow some states to change how they evaluate district performance for accountability purposes. We conclude with a discussion of the implications of our findings and recommendations that would make district accountability fairer and more meaningful, while preserving the goals of No Child Left Behind.
6
Assessments and Accountability
Robert L. Linn · Educational Researcher · 2000 · 681 citations
Education, Educational Assessment, Educational Measurement +17