Theorizing engagement: the potential of a critical dialogic approach

Jan Bebbington, Judy Brown, Bob Frame, Ian Thomson

Accounting Auditing & Accountability Journal · 2007 · 413 citations · 174 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The learning turn in social sciences has produced extensive theorizing from engagement activities that can guide and support engagement. The paper aims to enrich engagement discussions in social and environmental accounting by introducing a dialogic approach derived from critical inquiries, offering a new theoretical perspective. The authors synthesize literature from social and environmental accounting and related fields to develop a dialogic approach that derives principles for on‑ground engagements. Dialogic thinking fosters dialogic accountability, authentic engagements, and sustainable change, and the derived principles guide research design toward emancipatory outcomes.

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to contribute to discussions about engagement in social and environmental accounting, drawing on dialogic theory and philosophy. A dialogic approach, building on existing critical inquiries, is introduced to derive principles to inform “on the ground” engagements. Applying dialogic thinking to social and environmental accounting encourages the development of dialogic forms of accountability, more authentic engagements and is more likely to contribute to sustainable social and environmental change. Design/methodology/approach Contains a synthesis of literature from within and beyond social and environmental accounting to shed light on the issues addressed by the special issue. Findings Research engagements in social and environmental accounting need not be taken in a haphazard manner uninformed by theory. In particular, the “learning turn” in social sciences has generated a large body of theorizing (informed by concrete engagement activities) that can be used to shape, guide and support engagement. Practical implications The principles developed can be used to inform future research design, with the aim of increasing the likelihood that such engagements will yield outcomes of “value” usually defined as emancipatory changes. Originality/value This paper develops a new (to accounting) theoretical perspective.

References

174