Administrative Science Quarterly · 2010 · 255 citations · 120 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyEthicsJurisdictionMedical EthicsApplied EthicsLegal EthicsMoral PhilosophyNormative EthicsProfessional ResponsibilitySettlement PracticeJurisdictional RegulationMarketplace JurisdictionMoral Limits Of MarketsObservational Data CollectionPolicy LegitimizationProfessional JurisdictionRecognition Of Jurisdiction
The study investigates how U.S. cadaver commerce for medical education and research varies in perceived legitimacy across similar trade goods. Using archival, interview, and observational data from New York State, the authors analyze how market participants legitimize cadaver commerce and address jurisdictional disputes.
This study examines the U.S. commerce in human cadavers for medical education and research to explore variation in legitimacy in trades involving similar goods. It draws on archival, interview, and observational data mainly from NewYork State to analyze market participants' efforts to legitimize commerce and resolve a jurisdictional dispute. Building on literature on professions, the study shows that how goods are traded, not only what is traded, proves integral to constructing legitimacy, thus suggesting a practice-based view of moral markets. The professionals, including a group of “gatekeepers,” construct a narrative distinction between their own commerce and an implicitly less moral alternative and geographically insulate their trades from the broader commerce, creating in effect two circuits. Yet the professionals also promote specific practices of trade within their circuit to help them distinguish their own pursuit from an alternative course of action. The study's findings shed light on the micro-foundations of market legitimization and on the role of morals in sustaining professional jurisdictions.
120
Situated Learning: Legitimate Peripheral Participation.
Maurice Bloch, Jean Lave, Étienne Wenger · Man · 1994 · 39.8K citations
Managing Legitimacy: Strategic and Institutional Approaches
Mark C. Suchman · Academy of Management Review · 1995 · 12.5K citations