Community-Based Eco-Tourism on the Wild Coast, South Africa: The Case of the Amadiba Trail

Zolile Ntshona, Edward Lahiff

2003 · 27 citations · 4 references

Concepts

Abstract

This paper investigates the origins and current operation of the Amadiba Horse and Hiking Trail, a community-based initiative located on South Africa's Wild Coast. The trail project presents itself as a people-centred, designed to involve the Amadiba people in all aspects of running a project including planning, implementation, management and decision making. The benefits from the project are intended to accrue primarily to the Amadiba community.The involvement of a non-profit organisation, PondoCROP, in initiating the project, and the involvement of community representatives in operation and management, presented an alternative to large-scale investor driven development that could supplement, rather than replace, existing livelihood strategies.The key objective of this study is to investigate the actual involvement of the community in decision making processes, planning, management, control of the project, and also the kinds of benefits which accrue to the staff members, horse owners and the wider community. The evidence of this study would suggest the project has been at least partially successful in achieving its goals, but also raises questions about the model of a community-run project being applied in this case, and about the long-term economic sustainability of the project. This case study also highlights a number of key strengths and weaknesses of the community-based or bottom-up model of tourism development: There is market demand for ‘alternative’ tourist experiences, but operators must ensure that the service they offer is of consistent quality and meets the expectations of tourists. Poor rural people can combine work in the formal sector with ‘traditional’ local livelihood activities, but require appropriate (and ongoing) training, supervision, and reward structures.Local organisations can play a key role in the initiation and operation of tourism ventures, and mobilisation of local resources, but do not necessarily share the same interests as employees, and can become self-serving, especially as income begins to flow‘Community’ control does not necessarily translate into participatory or egalitarian organisations, as the growing centralisation of the Amadiba Trail demonstratesExternal agents have a crucial role to play in the identification and initiation of community-based projects, and NGOs would appear to be well suited to this role due to the open-ended nature of the relationship with the community and the uncertainly of financial returns. It is the quality and the duration of this relationship that is key, rather than the amount of funding available. This suggests that neither private interests nor donor organisations can adequately fill this role, and may even jeopardise the process with excessively tight deadlines and expectations of measurable returns.Trial-and-error, and evolutionary development, are integral to bottom-up initiatives. Nonetheless, there is a need for all parties concerned to be as clear as possible at each stage in the process about the aims of the project and the organisational form that it will take.While much can be achieved through participatory methods of organisation, it is not possible to dispense with professional management and administrative skills, including, in this case, some specialist knowledge of the tourism market. Such skills may be developed within the project over time, or sourced externally, or some combination of the two. The differential skilling of staff over time is likely to lead to tensions within the project, and impose real limitations to participatory forms of management.Experience and structures arising from one development project can increase the chances of attracting additional initiatives to an area. Projects do not necessarily need to be closely integrated and can serve different social groups within a community. Direct, personal benefits (for example, wages) are probably preferable to indirect ‘community’ benefits distributed through local structures. General funds placed in the hands of local structures are liable to be misused or spent on prestige goods, in ways that may not enhance the livelihoods of local people. Control of such funds may also become the basis for intense local debate and rivalry, with potentially disruptive consequences for the projects that generate them.External donor funding can help community-based organisation to grow, but also brings with it new requirements that have the potential to change the character of local projects. Expansion of organisational overheads on the basis of donor funding, rather than self-generated revenues, may distort organic growth and jeopardise sustainability in the longer term.

References

4