Is Science a Public Good? Fifth Mullins Lecture, Virginia Polytechnic Institute, 23 March 1993

Michel Callon

Science Technology & Human Values · 1994 · 373 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Governments should devote resources to basic research because science, viewed as a public good, provides diversity and flexibility and must be protected from market forces. The article argues that maintaining science as a public good requires abandoning traditional economic arguments and reversing conventional thinking about public goods. It uses insights from anthropology and sociology of science and technology to support this reversal.

Abstract

Should governments accept the principle of devoting a proportion of their resources to funding basic research? From the standpoint of economics, science should be considered as a public good and for that reason it should be protected from market forces. This article tries to show that this result can only be maintained at the price of abandoning arguments traditionally deployed by economists themselves. It entails a complete reversal of our habitual ways of thinking about public goods. In order to bring this reversal about, this article draws on the central results obtained by the anthropology and sociology of science and technology over the past several years. Science is a public good, not because of its intrinsic properties but because it is a source of diversity and flexibility.

References

29