International Journal of Science Education · 1994 · 48 citations · 10 references
Natural SciencesPhysicsScience EducationPhilosophy Of SciencePhysics EducationRelativityExperimental Tests Of RelativityPhilosophy Of PhysicsReference FramesClinical Assessment InterviewsConcrete ObjectsDiagnostic Test ProceduresFrame-based ConceptualizationFramesGalilean PhysicsHolistic CognitionReference Frame Definition
Abstract In this paper we investigate how students handle the abstract conceptual tool, namely, 'frames of reference', that is needed for the formulation and exploitation of the principle of relativity in physics. The methodology of probing into students' constructs is partly holistic and partly analytical. First, through a free‐response test and selected clinical interviews, we obtain holistic impressions of students' notions and assign them to a number of interpretative categories of responses. These are then grouped under a smaller number of superordinate categories of students' alternative conceptions. Guided by this phenomenology, a diagnostic forced‐option test is designed using a variety of situational contexts. The test is administered on a sample of 111 physics undergraduates drawn from different Bombay colleges. Students' responses are analysed to see the extent to which the alternative conceptions are held, and the consistency or otherwise between their various aspects. Our data show unmistakably that the more prevalent alternative conceptions are also the ones which are held with greater conviction. The analysis indicates that students implicitly associate 'frames of reference' with concrete objects, localized and bounded by the latter's extension; regard particular phenomena as 'belonging' to particular frames; allow value judgement on 'real' and 'apparent' [ness] of motion to co‐exist with their (learnt) knowledge about relativity of motion; and equate physical description to anthropomorphic viewing.
10
Research on conceptual understanding in mechanics
Lillian C. McDermott · Physics Today · 1984 · 627 citations
Constructivism in the computer age
Choice Reviews Online · 1989 · 520 citations
Children's conceptions of heat and temperature
Gaalen Erickson · Science Education · 1979 · 313 citations
Personal experience and the construction of knowledge in science
Maureen Pope, John Gilbert · Science Education · 1983 · 179 citations