A Dialectic Analysis of Generativity: Issues of Network-Supported Design in Mathematics and Science

Walter M. Stroup, Nancy Ares, Andrew C. Hurford

Mathematical Thinking and Learning · 2005 · 61 citations · 40 references

Concepts

Abstract

New theoretical, methodological, and design frameworks for engaging classroom learning are supported by the highly interactive and group-centered capabilities of a new generation of classroom-based networks. In our analyses, networked teaching and learning are organized relative to a dialectic of (1) seeing mathematical and scientific structures as fully situated in socio-cultural contexts and (2) seeing mathematics as a way of structuring our understanding of and design for group-situated teaching and learning. This dialectic provides a unique way of constructing understandings of the relationship between content and social activity. We believe that our approach to generative design, centering on the notion that classrooms have multiple agents interacting at various levels of participation and engagement, makes the best possible use of the plurality of emergent ideas found in classrooms. We review networked classroom examples that helped provoke our theoretical analyses. Features are presented for what we call generative design in terms of the respective “sides ” of the dialectic. Additional implications for activity design are then addressed. We close with an examination of how this dialectic framework also can support contructive critique of both sides of the dialectic in terms of content

References

40