How communication goals determine when audience tuning biases memory.

Gerald Echterhoff, E. Tory Higgins, René Kopietz, Stephan Groll

Journal of Experimental Psychology General · 2008 · 141 citations · 52 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Communicators' memories for original information are often biased toward the audience‑congruent view expressed in their tuned messages, creating an audience‑congruent memory bias. The study examined whether this bias depends on the communicators' goals driving audience tuning. Across four experiments, the bias was stronger when tuning aimed to create a shared reality than when it served nonshared reality goals such as politeness, incentives, entertainment, or compliance. The bias was mediated by epistemic trust in the audience‑congruent view, not by rehearsal, accurate retrieval, discrimination between original and message information, or contrast away from highly tuned messages, and meta‑analyses confirmed the central role of epistemic trust.

Abstract

After tuning their message to suit their audience's attitude, communicators' own memories for the original information (e.g., a target person's behaviors) often reflect the biased view expressed in their message--producing an audience-congruent memory bias. Exploring the motivational circumstances of message production, the authors investigated whether this bias depends on the goals driving audience tuning. In 4 experiments, the memory bias was found to a greater extent when audience tuning served the creation of a shared reality than when it served alternative, nonshared reality goals (being polite toward a stigmatized-group audience; obtaining incentives; being entertaining; complying with a blatant demand). In addition, the authors found that these effects were mediated by the epistemic trust in the audience-congruent view but not by the rehearsal or accurate retrieval of the original input information, the ability to discriminate between the original and the message information, or a contrast away from extremely tuned messages. The central role of epistemic trust, a measure of the communicators' experience of shared reality, was supported in meta-analyses across the experiments.

References

52