IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics · 2014 · 110 citations · 38 references
ComputingCommunicationOrganization StudiesOrganizational CommunicationTeamworkVisual AnalyticsCollaborative Knowledge SharingCollaborative SensemakingCollaborative Visual AnalyticsComputer-supported Cooperative WorkSensemakingSynchronous CollaborationActivitiesCollaboration SupportCollaborative AnalyticsCollaborative SpacesCommunication Support For Visual AnalyticsShared SensemakingUser Study EvaluationVisual Analytics Collaboration
Collaborative data analysis requires organizing, sharing, and coordinating findings, yet little is known about how tools can support sharing of externalizations such as notes, which are essential for team awareness and communication. The study investigates using linked common work (LCW) within a collaborative thinking space to enable synchronous collaborative sensemaking in visual analytics. The authors implemented CLIP, a collaborative thinking space that incorporates LCW features to expose relationships among collaborators’ findings, and evaluated it against a baseline version lacking LCW in a user study. Results show that LCW significantly improves analytic outcomes, enhances coordination and discussion among collaborators, and maintains awareness of each other’s activities without disruptive oral notifications.
When people work together to analyze a data set, they need to organize their findings, hypotheses, and evidence, share that information with their collaborators, and coordinate activities amongst team members. Sharing externalizations (recorded information such as notes) could increase awareness and assist with team communication and coordination. However, we currently know little about how to provide tool support for this sort of sharing. We explore how linked common work (LCW) can be employed within a `collaborative thinking space', to facilitate synchronous collaborative sensemaking activities in Visual Analytics (VA). Collaborative thinking spaces provide an environment for analysts to record, organize, share and connect externalizations. Our tool, CLIP, extends earlier thinking spaces by integrating LCW features that reveal relationships between collaborators' findings. We conducted a user study comparing CLIP to a baseline version without LCW. Results demonstrated that LCW significantly improved analytic outcomes at a collaborative intelligence task. Groups using CLIP were also able to more effectively coordinate their work, and held more discussion of their findings and hypotheses. LCW enabled them to maintain awareness of each other's activities and findings and link those findings to their own work, preventing disruptive oral awareness notifications.
38
The Nature of External Representations in Problem Solving
Jiajie Zhang · Cognitive Science · 1997 · 852 citations · Full text
Christopher Andrews, Alex Endert, Chris North · 2010 · 386 citations
Education, Instruction, Teaching +8
Design for individuals, design for groups
Carl Gutwin, Saul Greenberg · 1998 · 355 citations
Computing, Computer Science, Design +14