BMC Bioinformatics · 2014 · 65 citations · 26 references
ComputingBioinformaticsOncologyClinical Decision SupportFeature EngineeringMachine LearningBiomarker DiscoveryCancer BiomarkersFeature SelectionMolecular Classification Of TumorsMolecular Tumor ProfilingTumor ClassificationBiomarker-based ClassificationClassification AlgorithmsComputational Pipeline OptimizationGene Expression BiomarkersHigh-dimensional Data MiningMachine Learning Biomarker DiscoveryPredictive PerformanceTumor Biomarker Discovery
There is an ever-expanding range of technologies that generate very large numbers of biomarkers for research and clinical applications. Choosing the most informative biomarkers from a high-dimensional data set, combined with identifying the most reliable and accurate classification algorithms to use with that biomarker set, can be a daunting task. Existing surveys of feature selection and classification algorithms typically focus on a single data type, such as gene expression microarrays, and rarely explore the model's performance across multiple biological data types. This paper presents the results of a large scale empirical study whereby a large number of popular feature selection and classification algorithms are used to identify the tissue of origin for the NCI-60 cancer cell lines. A computational pipeline was implemented to maximize predictive accuracy of all models at all parameters on five different data types available for the NCI-60 cell lines. A validation experiment was conducted using external data in order to demonstrate robustness. As expected, the data type and number of biomarkers have a significant effect on the performance of the predictive models. Although no model or data type uniformly outperforms the others across the entire range of tested numbers of markers, several clear trends are visible. At low numbers of biomarkers gene and protein expression data types are able to differentiate between cancer cell lines significantly better than the other three data types, namely SNP, array comparative genome hybridization (aCGH), and microRNA data. Interestingly, as the number of selected biomarkers increases best performing classifiers based on SNP data match or slightly outperform those based on gene and protein expression, while those based on aCGH and microRNA data continue to perform the worst. It is observed that one class of feature selection and classifier are consistently top performers across data types and number of markers, suggesting that well performing feature-selection/classifier pairings are likely to be robust in biological classification problems regardless of the data type used in the analysis.
26
Scikit-learn: Machine Learning in Python
Fabián Pedregosa, Gaël Varoquaux, Alexandre Gramfort et al. · arXiv (Cornell University) · 2012 · 63.7K citations · Full text
Classification and Regression Trees.
Alexander Gordon, Leo Breiman, Jerome H. Friedman et al. · Biometrics · 1984 · 23.9K citations
An introduction to ROC analysis
Tom Fawcett · Pattern Recognition Letters · 2005 · 21.3K citations
Classification and Regression Trees.
John Van Ryzin, Leo Breiman, Jerome H. Friedman et al. · Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1986 · 21K citations
Gene Selection for Cancer Classification using Support Vector Machines
Isabelle Guyon, Jason Weston, S. Barnhill et al. · Machine Learning · 2002 · 9.8K citations · Full text