Winners and Losers: Changes in Texas University Admissions Post- <i>Hopwood</i>

Mark C. Long, Marta Tienda

Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis · 2008 · 112 citations · 22 references

Concepts

TL;DR

This study examines how the 1996 Hopwood decision altered the racial and ethnic makeup of admissions at three Texas universities. The authors estimated pre‑Hopwood affirmative‑action practices, assessed changes in the relative weighting of applicant characteristics during the ban, and simulated the impact of these new policies on minority admission rates. Universities eliminated direct advantages for black and Hispanic applicants, and although some weight adjustments helped underrepresented minorities, they were insufficient to restore their pre‑Hopwood admission shares.

Abstract

This paper evaluates changes in the racial and ethnic composition of admissions at three Texas universities following the judicial ban on affirmative action imposed by the 1996 Hopwood decision. We estimate the extent to which universities practiced affirmative action before the judicial ban, and evaluate how admission officers at these universities changed the relative weights accorded to various applicant characteristics during the ban. After assessing whether changes in the relative weights favored minority applicants, we simulate the degree to which these new policies succeeded in maintaining minority admission rates at their pre-Hopwood levels. We find that these universities complied with the Hopwood ruling such that direct advantages given to black and Hispanic applicants disappeared (and, in some cases, became disadvantages). While we find some evidence that universities changed the weights they placed on applicant characteristics aside from race and ethnicity in ways that aided underrepresented minority applicants, these changes in the admissions process were insufficient to fully restore black and Hispanic applicants' share of admitted students.

References

22