The Unfolded Protein Response Is Necessary but Not Sufficient to Compensate for Defects in Disulfide Isomerization

Jai-Hyun Kim, Yinsuo Zhao, Xuewen Pan, Xiangwei He, Hiram Gilbert

Journal of Biological Chemistry · 2009 · 13 citations · 24 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Pdi1p (protein-disulfide isomerase) is a folding assistant of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) that catalyzes disulfide formation and the isomerization of incorrect disulfides. Its disulfide forming activity is its essential function in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. A truncation mutant (Pdi1a′) that is competent in disulfide formation but deficient in catalyzing isomerization has only a small effect on growth, although the maturation of isomerase-requiring substrates (carboxypeptidase Y) is impaired (Xiao, R., Wilkinson, B., Solovyov, A., Winther, J. R., Holmgren, A., Lundstrom-Ljung, J., and Gilbert, H. F. (2004) J. Biol. Chem. 279, 49780–49786). We show here that there are multiple ways to compensate for defects in disulfide formation and isomerization in the ER. Genes of the unfolded protein response are induced, and deletions of the nonessential IRE1 or HAC1 genes are synthetically lethal. Diploid synthetic lethality analysis by microarray (dSLAM) using PDIa′ and a temperature-sensitive mutant of PDIa′ as query mutations reveals a group of 130 synthetically lethal genes. Only 10 of these correspond to genes clearly associated with the unfolded protein response. More than half are involved in vesicle traffic, not only out of and into the ER but anterograde and retrograde traffic from most cellular compartments. This suggests that defects in protein maturation in one intracellular compartment may be compensated for by adjusting vesicular traffic patterns throughout the cell. Pdi1p (protein-disulfide isomerase) is a folding assistant of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) that catalyzes disulfide formation and the isomerization of incorrect disulfides. Its disulfide forming activity is its essential function in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. A truncation mutant (Pdi1a′) that is competent in disulfide formation but deficient in catalyzing isomerization has only a small effect on growth, although the maturation of isomerase-requiring substrates (carboxypeptidase Y) is impaired (Xiao, R., Wilkinson, B., Solovyov, A., Winther, J. R., Holmgren, A., Lundstrom-Ljung, J., and Gilbert, H. F. (2004) J. Biol. Chem. 279, 49780–49786). We show here that there are multiple ways to compensate for defects in disulfide formation and isomerization in the ER. Genes of the unfolded protein response are induced, and deletions of the nonessential IRE1 or HAC1 genes are synthetically lethal. Diploid synthetic lethality analysis by microarray (dSLAM) using PDIa′ and a temperature-sensitive mutant of PDIa′ as query mutations reveals a group of 130 synthetically lethal genes. Only 10 of these correspond to genes clearly associated with the unfolded protein response. More than half are involved in vesicle traffic, not only out of and into the ER but anterograde and retrograde traffic from most cellular compartments. This suggests that defects in protein maturation in one intracellular compartment may be compensated for by adjusting vesicular traffic patterns throughout the cell. Eukaryotic proteins destined for extracellular locations are processed in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), 2The abbreviations used are: ER, endoplasmic reticulum; PDI, protein-disulfide isomerase; PDIa′, the C-terminal catalytic domain of S. cerevisiae Pdi1p; tsPDIa′, a temperature-sensitive mutant of PDIa′; wtPDI, wild type PDI; gPDI, genomic PDI; dSLAM, diploid synthetic lethality analysis by microarray; MM, magic medium; DTT, dithiothreitol; TRITC, tetramethylrhodamine isothiocyanate; UPR, unfolded protein response; PM, plasma membrane; GOAT, gene ontology analysis tool. where they fold and acquire the proper three-dimensional structure before exiting the ER to be delivered to their correct location (1Schroder M. Kaufman R.J. Annu. Rev. Biochem... 2005; 74: 739-789Google Scholar). For those proteins that require disulfide formation, the oxidizing environment of the ER and the presence of chaperones and folding catalysts, such as protein-disulfide isomerase (PDI), ensure that the proper cysteines are connected with disulfide bonds. PDI is an essential ER folding assistant present in all eukaryotes. PDI has two catalytic activities, oxidation of protein sulfhydryls into disulfides (oxidase activity) and the rearrangement of incorrectly formed disulfides (isomerase activity) (2Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 1997; 272: 29399-29402Google Scholar). PDI is composed of four structural domains, all with thioredoxin folds (3Edman J.C. Ellis L. Blacher R.W. Roth R.A. Rutter W.J. Nature.. 1985; 317: 267-270Google Scholar, 4LaMantia M.L. Lennarz W.J. Cell.. 1993; 74: 899-908Google Scholar). The active sites (CGHC) are in the N- and C-terminal thioredoxin domains (a and a′), separated by two structural/binding domains (b and b′). On an active site basis, the isolated a and a′ domains are capable of catalyzing disulfide formation in substrates at the same rate as the full-length protein, but a multidomain structure is required for catalyzing disulfide isomerization (5Darby N.J. Creighton T.E. Biochemistry.. 1995; 34: 11725-11735Google Scholar, 6Xiao R. Solovyov A. Gilbert H.F. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. J. Biol. Chem... 2001; 276: 27975-27980Google Scholar). Because PDI1 is an essential gene in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and is the only protein in yeast with significant disulfide isomerase activity, we were surprised to find that the a′ domain by itself expressed from the PDI1 promoter was sufficient to rescue the lethal pdi1Δ mutation (7Solovyov A. Xiao R. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 34095-34100Google Scholar). In addition, the amount of PDIa′ required to support nearly wild-type growth rates was within 2-fold of that of full-length PDI. The maturation of CPY, a yeast vacuolar protein that requires disulfide isomerization to rapidly gain its function, was significantly compromised (∼2-fold) despite the nearly normal growth rate. Although these observations confirm that the disulfide-forming activity of PDI (oxidase activity) is its essential function, they suggest that either essential yeast proteins do not require disulfide isomerization to fold correctly (CPY is a nonessential gene) or that there are unknown compensation mechanism at work. An obvious compensation mechanism would involve the up-regulation of the other ER homologues of PDI in yeast, Mpd1p, Mpd2p, Eug1p, or Eps1p. However, PDIa′ could still rescue the lethal PDI1 deletion with nearly normal growth even in a strain that had genomic deletions of all of the Pdi1p homologues (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google Scholar). Disulfide isomerization is part of an elaborate ER quality control system that ensures that proteins that cannot reach their native structure are retained in the ER until folding and post-translational modifications are completed or the misfolded protein is degraded (9Anelli T. Sitia R. EMBO J... 2008; 27: 315-327Google Scholar). When proper folding is compromised, part of the cell's response is to induce the unfolded protein response, a signaling pathway from the ER to the nucleus that is responsible for modifying expression to increase the supply of ER chaperones and folding catalysts, including PDI, to help mediate the consequences of accumulating unfolded proteins in the ER (10Ron D. Walter P. Nat. Rev... 2007; 8: 519-529Google Scholar). To explore mechanisms that might be required to compensate for defects in the isomerase activity of Pdi1p, we examined the induction of the PDI1 promoter, the mRNA levels of the PDI1 homologues, and the state of induction of the unfolded protein response. The normally nonessential unfolded protein response (UPR) becomes essential when the isomerase activity of Pdi1p is deficient. To detect other synthetically lethal genes, we applied the diploid synthetic lethality array method (dSLAM), where the competitive growth of a mixture of ∼6000 bar-coded individual deletion strains is examined by microarray analysis before and after replacing full-length PDI with the single catalytic domain, PDIa′, or a temperature-sensitive mutant of the PDIa′ domain (tsPDIa′). In addition to a number of genes involved in stress responses, including the UPR, the synthetically lethal genes we identified are involved in almost all aspects vesicular trafficking, including exocytic and endocytic pathways, and genes involved in regulating cell growth. Although limiting cell growth would diminish the requirement for the ER providing new membrane proteins, the other group of genes may be involved in regulating vesicle trafficking, possibly in an to the and of membrane proteins to a in the ER with the that the maturation of ER proteins in a in the rate of from the plasma with the of mechanisms to vesicle traffic within the cell. and strains were in with either or and For with wtPDI, PDIa′, or tsPDIa′, were on of synthetic magic yeast and synthetic and used A. 74: and promoter and in PDI or PDIa′ were from by the PDI of the PDI1 promoter in the site of of the PDI promoter from (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google was by and and into the J. T. J. by the same The was into pdi1Δ yeast strains and P. L. B. Winther J.R. J. 2001; Scholar). In the deletion of PDI1 was with a Pdi1p or The activity of yeast was the method of in 2005; Scholar). was as (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google using Pdi1p or PDIa′ as yeast PDIa′ and as a The protein was using the on the and were using the and T. L. J. M. B. 2005; Scholar). The was from of in a The was at for 10 and at for and at for analysis was on an using the PDI1 and PDIa′, and and and and and and and and To of genomic for gene were from A from the from of of was used in of with a of was in using as a at for was by of at for at for and at for The in in was by the system of the was using with and the addition of D. S. P. F. Cell.. 2004; Scholar). 10 of of and and a of and for The PDI1 a′ with the PDI promoter and was used as a were for at for for for for 10 The and were with and were into the PDI1 mutant strain To temperature-sensitive of PDIa′, the strain the PDIa′ was for at and on to pdi1Δ with a PDIa′ S. P. 2007; Scholar). were and after of at they were at either or of PDIa′ were and to the mutation and the isolated were into the PDI1 mutant strain to confirm the temperature-sensitive were for growth at and the for the synthetic lethality was on growth at the of yeast with a PDI1 query gene and a of PDI or PDIa′, the genomic PDI1 gene and of and were with a The was using the and the gene promoter and by into the PDI1 diploid mutant The was for and the the was on The was from using with are at almost and of The was used to the of diploid strains to the as S. P. 2007; to a of strains with one of the two PDI1 genes the diploid yeast in of at was at for to an of and with 10 of the the were to of and at for to expression of the gene and on were in to as D. S. P. F. Cell.. 2004; Scholar). A to on the of diploid strains was to of and with of a or The diploid strains were on and The were on with to for strains that a in a single gene and on of the strains in the a genomic of a and one other bar-coded gene The other half of the the a and one other bar-coded gene genomic was isolated from of strains to the genomic of with a genomic of To the genomic the diploid was on to for PDI and a genomic PDI1 was isolated from at as S. P. 2007; Scholar). To confirm the of was with for PDI genomic and the that PDI by in the PDI1 deletion The expression of PDIa′ in and strains the gene or gene was with array from the genomic of control or were using the or or and or were with and as S. P. 2007; Scholar). for or 10 of or or with either or and of genomic as and were were as for for 10 for for for For control the and were with the were using with The array is by that in of the To of the array an method was used where the and were The were as or or To the sites on to and were at 10 and at for and on and was in of and with and array was at with The array was and into of and and in of and of were using a and were using to the for For was and the was to an of for and were with and A was for Only with a of and the for all with an were Because the of may for from the and may be were when either the or was than a 2-fold in growth rate when PDI1 is by to multiple were from analysis S. P. 2007; Scholar). of of the individual synthetically lethal genes identified from the the individual diploid mutant strain was by a with the by with a as The strain was by to at for were in on to for the individual gene and an was on to with the PDI1 gene by the of were for at before with was in at and with in were in with for on To the were using were into and with at for A with an environment at was used for cell was at and was at were processed using or in the are single of an were to and the and were using B. A. A. J. Biochem... Scholar). The the that PDI1 is an essential yeast only its to disulfide formation (oxidase activity) is A single catalytic domain with than of the isomerase activity of Pdi1p support a wild-type growth rate R. Solovyov A. Gilbert H.F. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. J. Biol. Chem... 2001; 276: 27975-27980Google despite a 2-fold in the rate at a protein that requires disulfide (carboxypeptidase the ER. Its by a PDIa′ strain that disulfide isomerization is impaired and than in a wild-type strain (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google Scholar). disulfide on thioredoxin domains with a required in the catalytic are such proteins in the yeast ER and P. L. B. Winther J.R. J. 2001; that might compensate for the isomerase However, in a strain with all of the PDI homologues PDIa′ still support nearly wild-type growth, although the rate of from the ER is than wild-type (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google Scholar). When unfolded proteins in the ER, the expression of the PDI1 gene and other chaperones and folding is the L. Walter P. Cell.. Scholar). The expression of PDI1 and other genes may help compensate for to isomerase of the compensation mechanism may involve expression of Pdi1p or PDIa′ from the PDI1 To the of the activity of the PDI1 promoter in the presence of an isomerase promoter activity was examined in yeast strains by PDI1 or PDIa′ using a by the PDI1 in the PDI1 promoter is clearly when Pdi1p is by The expression from the PDI1 promoter in a small but significant increase in the of PDIa′ protein with wild-type as by the ER of PDI1 to a increase in the amount of PDIa′ protein expressed with wild-type the expression of PDIa′ with full-length Pdi1p, the of isomerase activity in is still to wild-type rates of maturation (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google Scholar). In a strain with deletions of all of the ER PDI homologues P. L. B. Winther J.R. J. 2001; the PDI1 promoter was even when wild-type PDI1 was and even when the PDI1 on the was by Because the PDIa′ protein of the isomerase activity of Pdi1p, the isomerization by up-regulation would still be to nearly normal growth significant growth is when the wild-type PDI1 levels are by (7Solovyov A. Xiao R. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 34095-34100Google Scholar). was used to the effect of isomerase activity on the expression of the ER homologues of PDI and with the ER that Pdi1p from its to and an essential ER that is to induction of the L. Walter P. Cell.. Scholar). with the and in A and replacing wild-type Pdi1p with PDIa′ in a significant increase in expression from the PDI1 promoter, as by the strain PDIa′ with DTT, is to induce the unfolded protein response L. Walter P. Cell.. in a increase in the mRNA expression levels of the PDI1 homologues and were only by replacing Pdi1p with However, the strains with that the unfolded protein response was not in the The expression of the ER was significantly when PDIa′ was as was the expression of the ER the genes we examined that were identified as part of the unfolded protein response and L. Walter P. Cell.. replacing with PDIa′ significant expression of only and For these genes, expression with that L. Walter P. Cell.. Scholar). However, the induction of the PDI1 homologues, and was not as in disulfide isomerization in the presence of PDIa′ may not in a unfolded protein response, although clearly genes are To the unfolded protein response is required for growth when PDI1 is with PDIa′, yeast strains were in the nonessential genes IRE1 or HAC1 were IRE1 and HAC1 the mechanism for the unfolded protein response L. Walter P. Cell.. Scholar). The deletion were from individual diploid yeast strains using the of the method D. S. P. F. Cell.. 2004; Scholar). The method with individual diploid strains in either the IRE1 gene or the HAC1 gene is with a of the two PDI1 genes in the diploid is with a and the diploid strains are with a either PDI1 or PDIa′ and for and the presence of the PDI the two strains and the Pdi1p or for only strains with a PDI1 deletion but only the other genes or are not The clearly show that deletion of either IRE1 or HAC1 is lethal when the only PDI present is PDIa′, but gene is essential when wild-type PDI1 is HAC1 and IRE1 the unfolded protein are synthetically with the of the PDI isomerase activity that one or genes are required to compensate for defects in disulfide Genes with the of there are other genes, including those of the response, that essential when PDI is the method D. S. P. F. Cell.. 2004; was applied to detect synthetically lethal on a To help a of defects in activity, a temperature-sensitive mutation was in PDIa′ This mutant a growth rate with that from at the but to at the its growth rate was half that by wild type Pdi1p or PDIa′ of the a single mutation at a site that is the of the a′ domain in the of the thioredoxin fold and from the active site rates of pdi1Δ by wild-type PDIa′, and PDI of at of at Pdi1p from wild type by with from wild type by with from wild type by with of at from wild type by with in a new To a of the ∼6000 individual deletions used in the the PDI1 gene was in the of strains with and the PDI was a one of the PDI PDIa′, or the control of the PDI1 four of strains were either in the presence and of The a of deletion that the full-length wild-type PDI1 on the and mutant that a wild-type PDIa′ or tsPDIa′, The a of strains that the wild-type PDI1 at its genomic were from the and by microarray to gene deletions that were in the of the PDI1 A of the is in of synthetic lethality in microarray A in all to not in in a new The four were in using microarray analysis to the of in is identified using a The part of the control genomic that was isolated from a of strains that has a wild-type PDI1 either in the or by a The part the genomic isolated from the of strains after of the gene The were and to the microarray and of at and the in was Because the of for from the and of strain may be significantly synthetic lethality genes were for analysis only the was than the and the or was than a 2-fold in growth rate when PDI1 was by PDIa′ or For of the the number of using these are in with the number of multiple The number of synthetically lethal when with wild-type full-length PDI1 is for the than PDIa′ that genes synthetically lethal when the gene is present at the To on those synthetically lethal genes that may the from were with the identified genes that were synthetically lethal in all were genes that were synthetically lethal in of the 130 genes identified as synthetic lethal are in help those genes with function, the of 130 synthetically lethal genes and the of genes in all were using the 2005; Scholar). This analysis genes in the using the S. cerevisiae gene ontology M. D. H. L. A. S. J.C. M. Nat. Scholar, J. S. and the of multiple genes from ontology on the number of genes that that and the number of gene A of genes were of the 130 genes identified by the genes that were in all all for still significantly even with the of the A of all 130 synthetically lethal genes with as to their in other and a of function be in A of the genes in of vesicle trafficking, not only into and out of the ER but cellular compartment where proteins are The other genes identified are involved with growth or growth stress responses, and protein the genes involved in of vesicle trafficking, a in In addition, the genes involved in vesicle all pathways, including anterograde and retrograde the ER, plasma and involved in vesicle that essential when disulfide is compromised by expression of PDIa′ or in pdi1Δ strains from the in the of individual deletion as in synthetic lethality by growth before for and the of growth after for for strains with a deletion in the genomic PDI1 the gene not a synthetically lethal even in the in the of not In that the gene deletion was as a synthetically lethal in all microarray of vesicle ER involved in ER ER ER ER ER ER ER ER ER pathway pathway pathway pathway of proteins to of proteins to of proteins to of proteins to of proteins to growth protein from the in the of individual deletion as in synthetic lethality by growth before for and the of growth after for for strains with a deletion in the genomic PDI1 the gene not a synthetically lethal even in the in the of not that the gene deletion was as a synthetically lethal in all microarray in a new The synthetic lethality of all of the genes involved in vesicle traffic was in individual strains and In addition, other genes, including were for synthetic lethality A of genes were examined the synthetically lethal The rate was and only one gene to in the of from the analysis is the pathway of the unfolded protein response, IRE1 and HAC1 (10Ron D. Walter P. Nat. Rev... 2007; 8: 519-529Google Scholar). of these genes had a in the control with from either the or to be the in of the gene was than 2-fold in all that they are not required when the isomerase activity of Pdi1p is two genes were examined for a synthetically lethal that these two genes are the of and M. N.J. A. T. J. B. N.J. Cell.. 2005; a for and for genes involved in aspects of ER quality control when the expression of the PDI1 gene is by the PDI1 mRNA by a For the 130 genes that we identified by the of the same genes. in the and The for the of in these two are not the in PDI1 expression in the could possibly genes that growth even than those by the PDI of the Genes to the induction of the unfolded protein response is required to compensate for defects in disulfide However, there is only a small amount of the 130 genes identified by in these and the genes that expression that used to the unfolded protein response on their and induction when protein folding in the ER is by or of L. Walter P. Cell.. Scholar). Only 10 of the 130 genes we identified here are part of the In addition, of the genes are not to or that although the unfolded protein response is to compensate for defects in the genes of the are not sufficient to rescue growth when the Pdi1p isomerase activity is deficient. of a of synthetically lethal genes involved in such a of vesicle and the that are involved in suggests the that one mechanism to help compensate for a of PDI such as (8Xiao R. Wilkinson B. Solovyov A. Winther J.R. Holmgren A. Lundstrom-Ljung J. Gilbert H.F. J. Biol. Chem... 2004; 279: 49780-49786Google from the ER would be to the rate of retrograde vesicle For would the for PDI substrates that function in the plasma membrane and compensate for a rate of their from the ER. there were in multiple of the and the in the of plasma membrane proteins from the system to the plasma membrane and the of plasma membrane proteins from J. Biol. Cell.. 2008; Scholar). The of the is and on yeast with at to the plasma and the to from the plasma as and in the membrane J. 1995; Scholar). The of is in For the rapidly in after the the to in vacuolar where When the isomerase activity of Pdi1p is compromised in the truncation the of in the may be the the of in the is than that by wild-type Pdi1p the in disulfide isomerization or formation in the ER by replacing Pdi1p with in a of into the may be with growth and of in yeast for Pdi1p, and PDI vacuolar are the of at four in the Pdi1p PDIa′ from wild type by with are the of at four in the from wild type by with in a new the unfolded protein response is essential to compensate for folding defects in the ER, the is not sufficient to compensate for the ER folding defects we In addition to the genes of the stress response, analysis of genes involved in the of vesicle that essential when disulfide isomerization and formation is compromised in the ER. is to the that there are essential proteins that require disulfide isomerization to the ER a significantly of PDI substrates from the ER might cellular function and mechanisms to The by the unfolded protein response is clearly one such mechanism S. Walter P. Annu. Rev. the of synthetic lethality and the that is in response to defects in the ER suggest that and signaling may vesicle and cell growth to help or defects in ER protein be required to the of these and the mechanisms that ER membrane traffic, and cell growth. with

References

24