Pathogens and Global Health · 2012 · 17 citations · 10 references
Veterinary MedicineInfectious DiseasesClinical MedicineDiagnostic MicrobiologyGood Laboratory PracticeDiagnostic EvaluationImage Quality AssessmentMalariaMicroscopic ExaminationReading AccuracyReading DifficultiesField HospitalsImage Reading ErrorMalaria MicroscopyMalaria ScreeningMalaria Smear ExaminationParasitological SurveysReadability In TestingSpecimen Quality Assessment
BACKGROUND: The WHO recommendation for parasitological diagnosis of malaria wherever possible is challenged by evidence of poor-quality microscopy in African hospitals but the reasons are not clear. METHODS: All 12 of the busier district hospital laboratories from three regions of Tanzania were assessed for quality of the working environment and slide readers read 10 reference slides under exam conditions. Slides that had been routinely read were removed for expert reading. RESULTS: Of 44 slide readers in the study, 39 (88.6%) correctly read >90% of the reference slides. Of 206 slides that had been routinely read, 33 (16%) were judged to be unreadable, 104 (51%) were readable with difficulty, and 69 (34%) were easily readable. Compared to expert reading of the same slide, the sensitivity of routine slide results of easily readable slides was 85.7% (95% confidence interval: 77.4-94.0), falling to 44.4% (95% confidence interval: 34.5-54.4) for slides that were 'readable with difficulty'. CONCLUSIONS: The commonest cause of inaccurate results was the quality of the slide itself, correction of which is likely to be achievable within existing resources. A minority of slide readers were unable to read slides even under ideal conditions, suggesting the need for a 'slide reading licence' scheme.
10
Malaria misdiagnosis: effects on the poor and vulnerable
Mark Amexo, Rachel Tolhurst, G. Barnish et al. · The Lancet · 2004 · 470 citations
Public Health, Infectious Diseases, Public Health Practice +12
Lawrence M. Barat, J Chipipa, MARGARETTE S. KOLCZAK et al. · American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene · 1999 · 136 citations
Veterinary Medicine, Infectious Disease Control, Infectious Diseases +17