Planning Perspectives · 1987 · 10 citations · 9 references
Social SciencesUrban PlanningHousingHousing PolicyUrban HistoryHousing DevelopmentHousing HistoryHousing Policy AnalysisPublic HousingHousing Policy HistoryHousing Policy ImplementationSlum ClearanceSmall Households
It is curious that despite widespread preoccupation with the use of flats in public housing since the Second World War, and despite the number of studies of the high flat ‘boom’ of the 1950s and 60s, there has been little interest in the arguments advanced for the flat during the 1940s. Yet the debate during these years, as the country was coming to focus on the task of reconstruction, was critical to the direction of housing policy and the forms of housing in the immediate post‐war years. During the mid 1940s we can see for the first time in Britain the elaboration of a broad‐based argument in favour of building flats, not just for special groups such as those being moved from slum clearance schemes, but as part of a general response to the problems of housing and reconstruction (Fig. 1). In the government publications that established the basis for reconstruction, such as the County of London Plan and the Housing Manual 1944, there is official encouragement for housing layouts that combined houses for large families with children and flats for small households, a form of housing known by the mid‐40s as ‘mixed development’. For London, Abercrombie proposed ‘rehousing in terms of a mixed lay‐out of housing and flats with the proportion of one to the other varying according to local conditions and requirements, thus producing a variety of treatment. It is believed that a balanced development of this kind would prove to be generally acceptable’. But what appeared acceptable to Abercrombie and Forshaw, and to the members of the Dudley Committee, whose report Design of Dwellings, published in 1944, was to shape the form of post‐war housing as the Tudor Walter Report had done in 1918, had certainly not been generally acceptable in 1939. Before the war the flat might have been acceptable for the rehoused slum dweller, or for the affluent needing a pied‐à‐terre in Town; it might have been acceptable to one or two large local authorities like London or Leeds, and to those who championed the cause of the New Architecture. But to most housing reformers and planners, to those associated with the Garden City movement and the Town and Country Planning Association, to those familiar with the inadequacies of the tenement housing built as a result of the slum clearance campaign of the 1930s, and to the great majority of the English public, the individual house with its garden was infinitely preferable to the flat. Yet by the end of the war flats were officially endorsed as a necessary form of housing for general purposes, were widely accepted as positive evidence of the progress of reconstruction, and were even, if the fragmentary survey information of authorities like the London County Council (LCC) is to be believed, viewed enthusiastically by their new tenants. What had brought about this change?
9
Utopia on trial: Vision and reality in planned housing
Habitat International · 1985 · 213 citations
The Neighborhood and the Neighborhood Unit
Lewis Mumford · Town Planning Review · 1954 · 164 citations
Utopia on trial: Vision and reality in planned housing
Ron Wiedenhoeft · Land Use Policy · 1986 · 153 citations
Reyner Banham · October · 2011 · 70 citations