Sociodynamic relationships between children who stutter and their non‐stuttering classmates

Stephen R. Davis, Peter Howell, Frances Cooke

Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry · 2002 · 317 citations · 23 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Earlier studies show that children who stutter are more often bullied and occupy lower social positions, but these findings are based on data over two decades old and may not reflect current attitudes shaped by recent integration and anti‑bullying policies. The authors applied a sociometric scale adapted from Coie, Dodge, and Coppotelli to 16 stuttering children and 403 classmates to evaluate peer relationships within classroom groups. Stuttering children were significantly more rejected, less popular, less likely to be nominated as leaders, and more likely to be labeled as bullied or seeking help, indicating that recent policy changes have had little effect on their social status and highlighting implications for schools and clinicians.

Abstract

Background: Previous research has indicated that children who stutter are more likely to be bullied and to hold a lower social position than their peers who do not stutter. However, the majority of this research has used data from respondents who were in the educational system more than 20 years ago. The current policy on integration of children with severe disabilities into mainstream education and the increased awareness of bullying in schools would indicate that attitudes toward children who stutter might have changed in the intervening period. Method: The study uses a sociometric scale (adapted from Coie, Dodge, & Coppotelli, 1982 ) to assess children who stutter in classroom groups with fluent peers. The peer relationships between 16 children who stutter and their classmates (403 children in total) were examined. Results: Children who stutter were rejected significantly more often than were their peers and were significantly less likely to be popular. When compared to children who do not stutter, the children who stutter were less likely to be nominated as `leaders' and were more likely to be nominated to the `bullied' and `seeks help' categories. Conclusions: The changes in integration policy and the implementation of anti‐bullying policies in many schools appear to have made little impact on the social status of children who stutter. The incidence of bullying and rejection reported in this study has implications for schools and clinicians.

References

23