Science and Engineering Ethics · 2014 · 91 citations · 9 references
EngineeringAerospace EngineeringAerial RoboticsInnovationUnmanned Aircraft SystemsAviation Infrastructure PolicyMilitary TechnologyActorsBorder Control PolicyBorder Control TechnologiesResponsible Research ConductUnmanned Aircraft Systems Regulation
RPAS, originally developed for military use, are now being advanced for diverse civilian roles, supported by regulatory changes, yet public acceptance is hindered by their military associations and potential controversial applications. The study examines this tension within the European agenda for responsible research and innovation. The authors evaluate whether current public acceptability strategies for RPAS align with responsible, socially beneficial civil development, without critiquing the drones themselves. They find that while a strong civil RPAS sector offers functional and economic benefits and potential military advantages, the European roadmap to avoid public rejection downplays military links and focuses on less controversial uses such as search and rescue.
Remotely piloted aviation systems (RPAS) or 'drones' are well known for their military applications, but could also be used for a range of non-military applications for state, industrial, commercial and recreational purposes. The technology is advanced and regulatory changes are underway which will allow their use in domestic airspace. As well as the functional and economic benefits of a strong civil RPAS sector, the potential benefits for the military RPAS sector are also widely recognised. Several actors have nurtured this dual-use aspect of civil RPAS development. However, concerns have been raised about the public rejecting the technology because of their association with military applications and potentially controversial applications, for example in policing and border control. In contrast with the enthusiasm for dual-use exhibited throughout the EC consultation process, the strategy for avoiding public rejection devised in its roadmap would downplay the connection between military and non-military RPAS and focus upon less controversial applications such as search and rescue. We reflect upon this contrast in the context of the European agenda of responsible research and innovation. In doing so, we do not rely upon critique of drones per se, in their neither their civil nor military guise, but explore the extent to which current strategies for managing their public acceptability are compatible with a responsible and socially beneficial development of RPAS for civil purposes.
9