Social impact assessment: the state of the art

Ana Maria Esteves, Daniel M. Franks, Frank Vanclay

Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal · 2012 · 664 citations · 35 references

DOIFull text

Open access

TL;DR

Social impact assessment is the process of managing the social issues of development, with consensus that good practice is participatory, supports stakeholders, enhances understanding, mitigates negative impacts, and benefits vulnerable people. This paper analyzes the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats facing SIA and argues that the community must revisit core concepts such as culture, community, power, human rights, gender, justice, place, resilience, and sustainable livelihoods. SIA practitioners should educate stakeholders and embed these core concepts into practice norms. Engaging with emerging trends like FPIC, human rights impact assessment, social performance standards, supply chain management, governance, local content, and economic development will improve SIA’s relevance and demonstrable value to all stakeholders.

Abstract

Social impact assessment (SIA) is now conceived as being the process of managing the social issues of development. There is consensus on what 'good' SIA practice is – it is participatory; it supports affected peoples, proponents and regulatory agencies; it increases understanding of change and capacities to respond to change; it seeks to avoid and mitigate negative impacts and to enhance positive benefits across the life cycle of developments; and it emphasizes enhancing the lives of vulnerable and disadvantaged people. We analyse the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats facing SIA. We assert that the SIA community needs to revisit core concepts, such as culture, community, power, human rights, gender, justice, place, resilience and sustainable livelihoods. It is incumbent on SIA practitioners to educate proponents, regulators and colleagues about these concepts, and to embed them into practice norms. Stronger engagement with the emerging trends of free, prior and informed consent (FPIC); human rights impact assessment; social performance standards; supply chain management; governance; local content and economic development will improve the relevance and demonstrable value of SIA to all stakeholders.

References

35