Biography · 2004 · 14 citations · 9 references
Social SciencesCultural StudiesHistoryHistoriographyJewish StudiesMemoryFalse MemoryHolocaust StudiesSurvivor TestimonyTrauma NarrativesEmotional IntensityHolocaust HistoriographyHolocaust NarrativesHolocaust Survivor TestimonyHolocaust TestimonyHolocaust VictimsTrauma-informed TestimonyWitnessing Suffering
Holocaust scholars often privilege survivor testimony by contrasting it with the more detached way history is traditionally studied. By communicating affect rather than fact through its gaps and inconsistencies, testimony's emotional intensity guarantees its authority. The scandal surrounding Binjamin Wilkomirski's Fragments, the false testimony of a troubled man, challenges trauma theory's tendency to identify with victims by showing that the author's trauma can be authentic even when his testimony is not. It is clear that Wilkomirski validated his personal suffering by attributing it to a broad human catastrophe. That such mistaken memory, or memory envy, could be so widely acclaimed challenges the ways we study and use the Holocaust within both American and American-Jewish culture.
9
Writing History, Writing Trauma
Debarati Sanyal, Dominick LaCapra · SubStance · 2002 · 1.7K citations
The Holocaust in American Life
Stanley Hoffmann, Peter Novick · Foreign Affairs · 1999 · 994 citations
Representing the Holocaust: History, Theory, Trauma.
John E. Toews, Dominick LaCapra · The American Historical Review · 1995 · 741 citations
Holocaust testimonies: the ruins of memory
Choice Reviews Online · 1991 · 692 citations
Norman Finkelstein · Index on Censorship · 2000 · 185 citations
Humanities, History, Jewish Studies +11