Journal of Chemical Information and Computer Sciences · 1996 · 633 citations · 18 references
PharmacyMedicinal ChemistryPharmacologyDrug DesignDrug DiscoveryStructure-activity RelationshipsChemical Library DesignChemical Space ExplorationComputational Drug DiscoveryMolecular DescriptorsQuantitative Structure-activity RelationshipsStructure-activity Relationship AnalysisCompound PrioritizationDescriptor-based ModelingHierarchical ClusteringPharmacophore Cluster AnalysisPharmacophore ClusteringPharmacophore Feature ExtractionSelection Method Combinations
The study evaluates various structure‑based clustering methods for selecting compounds. The authors compare 2D descriptors (MACCS, Unity, Daylight) and 3D descriptors (Unity rigid/flexible and two in‑house pharmacophore‑based) with Ward, group‑average, Guénoche, and Jarvis‑Patrick clustering algorithms. 2D descriptors combined with hierarchical clustering, particularly MACCS with Ward’s method, most effectively separate active from inactive compounds.
An evaluation of a variety of structure-based clustering methods for use in compound selection is presented. The use of MACCS, Unity and Daylight 2D descriptors; Unity 3D rigid and flexible descriptors and two in-house 3D descriptors based on potential pharmacophore points, are considered. The use of Ward's and group-average hierarchical agglomerative, Guénoche hierarchical divisive, and Jarvis−Patrick nonhierarchical clustering methods are compared. The results suggest that 2D descriptors and hierarchical clustering methods are best at separating biologically active molecules from inactives, a prerequisite for a good compound selection method. In particular, the combination of MACCS descriptors and Ward's clustering was optimal.
18
Journal of the American Statistical Association
Robert Fildes · International Journal of Forecasting · 1989 · 3.7K citations
Peter Willett, Vivienne Winterman · Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationships · 1986 · 202 citations