Child Development · 1985 · 483 citations · 35 references
Social SciencesBehavioral SciencesPsychologyChild DevelopmentDevelopmental PsychologyFamily AssessmentChild AssessmentParent-child InteractionParent-child RelationshipsParentingChild Rearing DecisionsFamily Behavior AssessmentParent-child Interaction AssessmentParent-offspring InteractionParental Behavior
This study of the reliability and validity of scales from the Child's Report of Parental Behavior (CRPBI) presents data on the utility of aggregating the ratings of multiple observers. Subjects were 680 individuals from 170 families. The participants in each family were a college freshman student, the mother, the father, and 1 sibling. The results revealed moderate internal consistency (M = .71) for all rater types on the 18 subscales of the CRPBI, but low interrater agreement (M = .30). The same factor structure was observed across the 4 rater types; however, aggregation within raters across salient scales to form estimated factor scores did not improve rater convergence appreciably (M = .36). Aggregation of factor scores across 2 raters yields much higher convergence (M = .51), and the 4-rater aggregates yielded impressive generalizability coefficients (M = .69). These and other analyses suggested that the responses of each family member contained a small proportion of true variance and a substantial proportion of factor-specific systematic error. The latter can be greatly reduced by aggregating scores across multiple raters.
35
Construct validity in psychological tests.
Lee J. Cronbach, Paul E. Meehl · Psychological Bulletin · 1955 · 10.9K citations · Full text
Peter Madison, Walter Mischel · The American Journal of Psychology · 1968 · 4.4K citations
Tests for comparing elements of a correlation matrix.
James H. Steiger · Psychological Bulletin · 1980 · 4.4K citations
Review of Child Development Research
James Walters, Martin L. Hoffman, Lois Wladis Hoffman · Journal of Marriage and the Family · 1965 · 3.7K citations