Management Effectiveness of the World's Marine Fisheries

TLDR

Declining global fisheries production threatens ecological and socioeconomic stability, prompting international initiatives to improve management, yet the effectiveness of these measures remains largely unknown. The authors surveyed 1,188 of 13,000 fisheries experts, validated responses with empirical data, and calculated the sustainability of reported catches to evaluate how management regimes influence fisheries sustainability. Only 7 % of coastal states conduct rigorous scientific assessments, 1.4 % have participatory transparent processes, and 0.95 % enforce compliance, yet the conversion of scientific advice into policy through participatory transparency is central to achieving sustainability, highlighting the urgent need for guideline implementation.

Abstract

Ongoing declines in production of the world's fisheries may have serious ecological and socioeconomic consequences. As a result, a number of international efforts have sought to improve management and prevent overexploitation, while helping to maintain biodiversity and a sustainable food supply. Although these initiatives have received broad acceptance, the extent to which corrective measures have been implemented and are effective remains largely unknown. We used a survey approach, validated with empirical data, and enquiries to over 13,000 fisheries experts (of which 1,188 responded) to assess the current effectiveness of fisheries management regimes worldwide; for each of those regimes, we also calculated the probable sustainability of reported catches to determine how management affects fisheries sustainability. Our survey shows that 7% of all coastal states undergo rigorous scientific assessment for the generation of management policies, 1.4% also have a participatory and transparent processes to convert scientific recommendations into policy, and 0.95% also provide for robust mechanisms to ensure the compliance with regulations; none is also free of the effects of excess fishing capacity, subsidies, or access to foreign fishing. A comparison of fisheries management attributes with the sustainability of reported fisheries catches indicated that the conversion of scientific advice into policy, through a participatory and transparent process, is at the core of achieving fisheries sustainability, regardless of other attributes of the fisheries. Our results illustrate the great vulnerability of the world's fisheries and the urgent need to meet well-identified guidelines for sustainable management; they also provide a baseline against which future changes can be quantified.