Framing-effects approach: A theoretical and methodological critique

Bertram Scheufele

Communications · 2004 · 229 citations · 50 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The article reviews research on framing effects. The study aims to classify framing approaches and discuss framing-effect studies in theory, methods, and empirical results. The authors define frame, schema, and framing concepts, review theoretical and operational framing research, and discuss studies of framing effects. The review concludes that framing-effect studies neglect newer psychological constructs, focus too narrowly on schema activation, and leave many empirical questions unanswered, wasting methodological opportunities.

Abstract

The article deals with research on framing effects. First, I will start with classifying different approaches on framing. Subsequently, I will provide a definition of the concepts of frame, schema and framing, expand on framing research conducted so far – both theoretically and operationally. Having this equipment at hand, I will initiate a discussion on studies of framing-effects in terms of theory, methods and empirical results. This discussion leads to the conclusion that studies on framing effects are insufficiently concerned with the more recent psychological constructs and theories. In merely focusing on the activation of schemata, most studies ignore the more elaborate types of framing-effects. Therefore, several empirical questions remain unanswered and some methodical chances seem to be wasted.

References

50