The relationship between total quality management practices and organizational culture

TLDR

This empirical study explores the relationship between total quality management (TQM) practices and organizational culture, testing unitarist versus pluralist views to identify which cultures enable successful TQM implementation. Using data from 194 Australian organizations, the authors applied the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award criteria as a TQM framework and the competing values model of culture, analyzing the relationships with structural equation modeling. Results support the pluralist view, showing that different TQM practices are linked to distinct culture types, with hierarchical culture significantly related to certain practices, yet organizations can harmoniously implement diverse, even conflicting, TQM elements.

Abstract

Purpose This empirical study explores the relationship between total quality management (TQM) practices and organizational culture with the purpose of identifying the particular cultures that determine the successful implementation of TQM practices. Specifically, it tests two competing views on the relationship; the unitarist and pluralist views. Design/methodology/approach The empirical data was drawn from 194 organizations in Australia. The research model employs the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award criteria as TQM framework and builds on the competing values model to frame organizational culture. The data was analysed using structural equation modelling technique. Findings The findings support the pluralist view, wherein different subsets of TQM practices are determined by different types of cultures. Interestingly, hierarchical culture was found to have a significant relationship with certain practices of TQM. Additionally, the findings indicate that although the cultural factors underpinning different elements of TQM are dissimilar, even antagonistic, organizations can implement them in harmony. Practical implications The major implication of this study is that organizations need to accommodate divergent goals by developing a system and/or structure that allows enough flexibility for adapting different (even contrasting) management styles, between control and flexibility and between internal and external orientations, so that they may gain benefits from the multiple dimensions of TQM. Originality/value This paper provides empirical evidence on the multidimensionality of TQM practices along with their association with different types of culture.