Nostalgia and the Emotional Tone and Content of Song Lyrics

Krystine Irene Batcho

The American Journal of Psychology · 2007 · 170 citations · 23 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study manipulated emotion and topic in song lyrics and had participants complete nostalgia surveys while rating six lyric sets on affective and thematic dimensions. Nostalgic lyrics evoke bittersweet reverie, loss, identity, and meaning; individuals high in personal nostalgia prefer happy, meaningful lyrics and identify more closely with them, favor other-directed themes, whereas historical nostalgia is linked to a stronger connection with sad lyrics.

Abstract

Emotion and topic were manipulated in original song lyrics. Participants completed Batcho's and Holbrook's nostalgia surveys and rated 6 sets of lyrics for happiness, sadness, anger, nostalgia, meaning, liking, and relevance. Nostalgic lyrics were characterized by bittersweet reverie, loss of the past, identity, and meaning. Contrary to theories linking nostalgia to pathology, participants who scored high on Batcho's measure of personal nostalgia preferred happy lyrics, found them more meaningful, and related more closely to them. Consistent with theories relating nostalgia to social connectedness, high-nostalgia respondents preferred other-directed to solitary themes. Historical nostalgia was associated with relating more closely to sad lyrics.

References

23