Not the usual suspects: How to use board process to make boards better

Sydney Finkelstein, Ann C. Mooney

Academy of Management Perspectives · 2003 · 500 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Research on corporate boards has focused on board independence, yet classic indicators such as outsider count, shareholdings, size, and CEO duality fail to produce strong results or robust governance. This article argues that true board effectiveness depends on board process rather than the usual suspects. The authors conducted structured interviews with board members to reveal actual boardroom dynamics. Their analysis identifies five critical goals for boards and offers a detailed checklist of recommendations to achieve them.

Abstract

Executive Overview Research on corporate boards and board reform efforts alike have been dominated by a concern for board independence and its effect on the monitoring of the CEO. However, attention to what we call the "usual suspects"—the number of outsiders on boards, director shareholdings, board size, and whether the CEO also holds the Chair position (CEO duality)—does not yield either strong research results or more robust corporate governance in practice. In this article we argue that the "usual suspects," as measured by the classic indicators, do not ensure a truly independent board and that the key to making boards work better rests in an area largely ignored by researchers: board process. Based on structured interviews with members of corporate boards, we open a window to what is really going on inside boardrooms. Our analysis suggests five critical goals for which all boards should strive and presents a detailed checklist of recommendations for directors on how best to realize these goals.