2001 · 10 citations · 21 references
EducationEducational MeasurementCausal InferenceEconometricsIndividual DifferencesAbility EstimationPeer Group DynamicsPeer InfluencePeer InteractionStudent Achievement AnalysisPeer EffectsPeer Group InfluencePeer Influence On Achievement
Empirical analysis of peer effects on student achievement has been open to question because of the difficulties of separating peer effects from other confounding influences. While most econometric attention has been directed at issues of simultaneous determination of peer interactions, we argue that issues of omitted and mismeasured variables are likely to be more important. We control for the most important determinants of achievement that will confound peer estimates by removing student and school-by-grade fixed effects in addition to observable family and school characteristics. The analysis also addresses the reciprocal nature of peer interactions and the interpretation of estimates based upon models using past achievement as the measure of peer group quality. The results indicate that peer achievement has a positive effect on achievement growth. Moreover, students throughout the school test score distribution appear to benefit from higher achieving schoolmates. On the other hand, the variance in achievement appears to have no systematic effect. Eric A. Hanushek John F. Kain Hoover Institution Green Center for the Study of Stanford University Science and Society Stanford, CA 94305-6010 University of Texas at Dallas and NBER P.O. Box 830688 hanushek@hoover.stanford.edu Richardson, TX 75083-0688 Jacob M. Markman Steven G. Rivkin Department of Economics Department of Economics Amherst College Amherst College Amherst, MA 01002 Amherst, MA 01002 Does the Ability of Peers Affect Student Achievement? by Eric A. Hanushek, John F. Kain, Jacob M. Markman, and Steven G. Rivkin The peer group composition of schools is undeniably important in the minds of parents as well as policy makers at the local, state, and federal level. Residential location decisions of families, various state and federal laws, and court interpretations of school district policies frequently have an implicit if not explicit peer group component. There have nonetheless been relatively few direct investigations of the impact of peer groups on student performance and what evidence exists has been open to widely varying interpretations. This paper pursues a unique identification strategy based on small perturbations in cohort composition to extract the causal impacts of peer group characteristics on achievement. Peer group effects have played a prominent role in a number of policy debates including ability tracking, anti-poverty programs in both rural areas and urban ghettos, and school desegregation. In addition, opposition to the growing demand for expanded school choice or the provision of education vouchers often focuses on the importance of peers and potential for greater economic and social isolation of disadvantaged students. At the same time advocates of choice often tout its potential for reducing the impact of neighborhood economic and racial segregation. The role of peers also has entered increasingly into theoretical analyses of school choice. Starting from the observation that many people express concern about other students, a variety of analyses (e.g., Benabou (1993, 1996), Caucutt (forthcoming), de Bartolome (1990), and Epple and Romano (1998)) have examined the equilibrium properties of choice and peer group effects on student achievement. This attention to peer effects has taken place largely in the absence of compelling empirical evidence on the impact of peer group characteristics on a variety of academic, social, and labor market outcomes. As Brock and Durlauf (forthcoming), Manski (1993) and Moffitt (2001) point out, the empirical analysis of peer influences has been inhibited by both conceptual and data problems -problems that raise serious questions about interpretation of the existing
21
EQUALITY OF EDUCATIONAL OPPORTUNITY
James S. Coleman · Equity & Excellence in Education · 1968 · 5.3K citations
What money can't buy: family income and children's life chances
Choice Reviews Online · 1997 · 955 citations