New paradigms for quality in primary care.

Bárbara Starfield

PubMed · 2001 · 185 citations · 22 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Primary care is essential for an effective health system, yet its quality measurement remains in its infancy, relying largely on outdated audit models and limited functional outcome data. The paper aims to investigate how evidence of appropriateness can serve as a foundation for evaluating quality of care interventions. The authors observe that self‑reported functional assessment tools are gaining recognition as vital quality indicators, but robust implementation and validation are still lacking.

Abstract

HERE is no longer any doubt of the importance of primary care as the key to an effective and efficient health service. Primary care, defined in terms of the achievement of its four functions, can be measured and its quality assessed. But, as in all forms of human endeavour, science and society change over time, providing primary care with new challenges. The science of quality measurement is, at best, still in its adolescence. 1 For the most part, current approaches to assessing quality of care are based on models developed a half-century ago. At that time, the techniques of medical audit of the processes of care were developed to assess the extent to which generally recognised features of care, such as preventive procedures, indicated screening tests, and appropriate management strategies for specific conditions, were performed by practitioners. These are still the stock-intrade of virtually all quality assessment schemes today with relatively minor modification. First, evidence for appropriateness is increasingly sought as the basis for making judgments about indicated interventions. Secondly, satisfaction surveys have been added to the armamentarium of quality assessments, although these types of assessments are arguably more useful for marketing of competing health plans than for assessing the quality of care. Outcomes of care, as characterised by self-reported functional assessment instruments, are increasingly recognised as important measures of quality; however, there have been no serious

References

22