Civility in the city: blacks, Jews, and Koreans in urban America

Unknown author(s)

Choice Reviews Online · 2003 · 176 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Media portray inner‑city retail stores as scenes of racial conflict. The study investigates how African American, Jewish, and Korean merchants interact with black customers in New York and Philadelphia, showing that everyday civility is the norm and probing why rare clashes erupt into larger conflicts. Civility is maintained through daily negotiations and merchants’ proactive investments to manage tensions and preserve routine. Most interactions are civil, but rare conflicts arise from poverty, inequality, and the presence of socially mobile newcomers—an occurrence largely ignored by the media.

Abstract

Hollywood and the news media have repeatedly depicted the inner-city retail stores as a scene of racial conflict and acrimony. in the City uncovers a quite different story. Jennifer Lee examines the relationships between African American, Jewish, and Korean merchants and their black customers in New York and Philadelphia, and shows that, in fact, social order, routine and civility are the norm. Lee illustrates how everyday civility is negotiated and maintained in countless daily interactions between merchants and customers. While merchant-customer relations are in no way uniform, most are civil because merchants actively work to manage tensions and smooth out incidents before they escalate into racially charged anger. Civility prevails because merchants make investments to maintain the day-to-day routine, recognizing that the failure to do so can have dramatic consequences. How then do minor clashes between merchants and customers occasionally erupt into the large-scale conflicts we see on television? Lee shows how inner-city poverty and extreme inequality, coupled with the visible presence of socially mobile newcomers, can provide fertile ground for such conflicts. The wonder is that they occur so rarely, a fact that the media ignore.