The New Literary Middlebrow: Tastemakers and Reading in the Twenty-First Century

John Frow

Journal of the Association for the Study of Australian Literature · 2014 · 32 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Beth Driscoll. The New Literary Middlebrow: Tastemakers and Reading in the Twenty-First Century. Houndmills and New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014. 240 pp. ISBN: 9781137402912 (Hardcover: £55.00) 9781137402936 (EPUB: AU$61.86) 9781137402929 (PDF: AU$126.53) http://www.palgrave.com/page/detail/the-new-literary-middlebrow-bethdriscoll/?K=9781137402912One of the things the sociology of reading usefully does is challenge the givenness of structures of value we tend to take for granted. It documents the way in which particular values tend to become associated with particular social groups, and it undermines the hierarchies of value with which academic literary studies implicitly works.Recent studies of middlebrow culture, beginning with Joan Rubin's The Making of Middlebrow Culture (1992) and Janice Radway's A Feeling for Books: The Book-of-the-Month Club, Literary Taste and Middle-Class Desire (1997), have delineated a reading formation prevalent in the mid-twentieth century which is at once highly commercial and culturally aspirational: a culture of reverence for 'quality' writing which it wants in an easily digestible form (the Reader's Digest is one of its manifestations). Beth Driscoll's study extends this analysis into the contemporary period, focusing on a number of key institutions of middlebrow culture: the book club, and its mass-mediated model in Oprah's Book Club; the use of the Harry Potter novels to teach particular engaged and identificatory ways of reading; the world of literary prizes; and the literary festival. Middlebrow culture in the contemporary worldis personalized book recommendations on Amazon, or a cafe in the middle of an independent bookstore. It is a literary prize's Twitter feed or a movie star's soldout appearance at a writer's festival. It is online cultural magazines such as Salon.com or Slate.com, or a book club that watches Austen TV adaptations. (5)What holds all this together is a set of characteristics that roughly define a distinctive formation: middlebrow culture is 'middle-class, reverential towards elite culture, entrepreneurial, mediated, feminized, emotional, recreational and earnest' (6).Now, much of this seems to me to be straightforwardly accurate, and Driscoll does a thorough and thoughtful job of working out the cultural and institutional dimensions of her analysis. In particular, she makes a strong case for there being a distinctively feminised mode of reading, which values affective identification with characters, which looks for a reflection of its own experiences in their lives, and which is 'ethical' in the sense of exercising moral judgement on a world that is taken to be close to the real world: this regime looks for 'stories of personal growth and moral redemption,' and sees reading 'as part of a larger project of moral improvement' (40). Lauren Berlant's model of the intimate public sphere-the creation of a 'porous, affective scene of identification among strangers that promises a certain experience of belonging' (63, citing Lauren Berlant, The Female Complaint)-is appropriately invoked here, although I think Driscoll misses Berlant's point about the politically fantasmatic nature of this scene of identification. The chapter on Oprah admirably fleshes out the characteristics of this feminised and therapeutic mode of reading, and it's nicely complemented by the chapter on literary festivals, which are 'attended predominantly by middle-class women, promote reading practices that are emotional, earnest and highly mediated, inflected by respect for literary stars and enmeshed in the commercial structures of the publishing industry' (153).My concern, however, is with what exactly it means to call this reading formation 'middlebrow,' and what it means to call it 'middle class.' Let me make a couple of subsidiary points before I take up this concern. First, the feminised reading formation described here has much older antecedents than the mid-twentieth-century culture of the various Great Books series, the Reader's Digest, and the Book-of-the-Month Club; Driscoll alludes briefly to the prevalence of female authors in the early history of the novel, and it might have been useful to explore Nancy Armstrong's argument about the role of 'domestic fiction' in forming the culture-and thereby the hegemonic social role-of the English middle classes in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. …