Identity That Makes a Difference: Substantial Learning as Closing the Gap between Actual and Designated Identities.

Anna Sfard, Anna Prusak

2005 · 59 citations · 7 references

Concepts

Abstract

In the attempt to account for striking differences between learning activities of immigrant mathematics students from the former Soviet Union and of their native Israeli classmates, we introduce the notions of actual and designated identities. These identities are subsequently presented as important factors that mold learning and influence its effectiveness. Since designated identities may be seen as personalized, “customized ” versions of people’s cultural heritages, ours is the story of the wider culture making its way into individual learning processes. [For me,] school mathematics was … something that one cannot escape and must try to be done with as quickly as possible … The numbers did not scare me; rather the scary part was my complete lack of interest in them … All that I remember now is my constant effort to match formulas with exam questions. This quote from a retrospective account of a successful university student 1 is unlikely to surprise a person who knows a thing or two about mathematics learning and teaching. We are all only too familiar with this kind of unhappy reminiscences. Much less common are reports about mathematics-related experiences of interest and joy,

References

7