2000 · 21 citations · 0 references
EducationTeacher EducationTeachingInstructional LeadershipPedagogyTeacher PolicyTeacher ExpectationsTeacher HiringTeacher RecruitmentTeacher RetentionTeacher Working ConditionsNovice Teacher RetentionPre-service Teacher EducationRetention Of Novice TeachersTeacher PerceptionsTeaching Behavior
Perceptions of the High School Teacher The expected shortages across the United States and the higher learning standards being proposed in virtually every state have left colleges of education and pre-service teachers reeling. We are in dire need of a number of teachers, and most of these will be young, recent college graduates. However, these newly minted teachers can not be expected to start out as experts. Contemporary education graduates have been exposed to a magnitude of theory and practical information associated with effective teaching. So much, perhaps, that they can't begin to integrate great teaching into their daily practice. These novice teachers begin their careers often times with a feeling that if they were just not then they could get by until they are good. Interestingly, with the volumes of research dictating what it means to be a teacher, it is almost impossible to identify a body of literature addressing the issue of teaching, namely specific examples of what novice teachers should avoid. As one newly hired English recently put it, What not to be is the real question. This study compares perceptions of the bad high school teacher as gathered in interviews with high school administrators, teachers, parents and students. Results show patterns of negative behaviors that are both informative and interesting. Our discussion offers suggestions to teachers on how to avoid being awful ... and a list of reminders of positive behaviors as well. As students begin the process of becoming a through a formal education program, they often hold out hope that they will become outstanding. Models for high quality are often rolled out and shown off both to inspire these novices AND to show what teachers do. The literature abounds with such images, for example, Haberman has described Star urban teachers (1995), Ladson-Billings (1994) has told us about Culturally Relevant Teachers who have been superb. Lightfoot (1983) has identified good high schools and Dyer's (1996) survey identified the ten desirable traits of successful teachers. Seldom, however, have images of the been available. Dyer's study produced a student survey showing qualities of effective and ineffective teachers, albeit these characteristics were presented on a continuum (a forced-choice approach). Another recent source, a text called Bad Teachers: The Essential Guide for Concerned Parents (Strickland, 1998) ostensibly offers a handbook to help parents deal with lousy teachers and the administrators who protect them. While providing no definition of teaching, Strickland provides exemplars embedded in stories told by youngsters about school. Strickland does offer seven attributes that lead to a description of bad teachers: 1. They lack subject knowledge 2. They have poor classroom control 3. They act unprofessionally 4. They can't diagnose learning problems 5. They are obsessive about method (particularly about whole language, although he himself is obsessive about phonics and is an avid opponent of Madeline Hunter's work). 6. They focus on the wrong goals 7. They have no goals at all In truth, avoidable qualities and undesirable images of high school teachers have not been investigated very well ... and the result has been a belief that badness is the opposite or the absence of goodness qualities. We saw this belief as a hypothesis worth deep investigation within our University community. We had already suspected that incoming teachers were less marked by a passion to be great than they were horrified at the thought of being bad. Make no mistake, almost all of the novices wanted to become and had confidence that they would be highly successful ... but that was a long term goal. In the short run, they didn't want to be a disaster: they wished to survive student teaching so that they could grow and develop as they profited from experience. …