Labor Arbitration and Dispute Resolution

Julius G. Getman

The Yale Law Journal · 1979 · 28 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

There is a widespread perception that our judicial system needschanging. It is expensive, unnecessarily technical, intrusive on privaterelations, and it gives unfair advantage to the wealthy and powerful.Labor arbitration, by contrast, is frequently pointed to as the paradigmof private justice.It is understandable that labor arbitration is widely admired. Whenit functions properly it achieves in an impressive fashion the goals bywhich any system of dispute resolution should be measured. These are:(1) Finality. Once decided, are cases likely to be retried or appealed?(2) Obedience. Are the decisions put into effect or are they renderedmeaningless by subsequent refusals to carry them out?(3) Guidance. Do the decisions provide necessary guidance to theparties involved in the dispute? Can they subsequently structure behaviorin a reasonable fashion and avoid future litigation?(4) Efficiency. Are the majority of disputes settled without a formalhearing? When cases are tried, are the procedures adequate, flexible,and suited to the particular issue? Are the benefits achieved from thesystem economical compared to the costs?(5) Availability. Is the dispute-resolution machinery routinely availablewithout undue expense to people whose behavior is governed bythe system, and are they provided with adequate representation?(6) Neutrality. Do the decision makers avoid favoritism and bias forone side or another?(7) Conflict Reduction. Does the entire process, including the adjudication,lead to more amicable relations and contribute to mutual respectamong the potential disputants?(8) Fairness. Will the disputes be resolved in a way that appropriatelyrecognizes the interests of the various parties likely to come before thesystem?