The Delta Kappa Gamma bulletin · 2013 · 18 citations · 0 references
EducationHigher EducationScience EducationScience InstructionSecondary Science EducationStem EducationCareer PathwaysStudent InterestCollege Readiness In StemCritical Thinking CompetenceCritical Thinking CompetenciesStem AspirationsStem Career ReadinessStem Degree AttainmentStudent Engagement In Stem
The United States has lost its competitive edge in math and science education (National Math + Science Initiative, 2013), and work in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) is no longer a career of choice. Some studies attribute these trends to lack of student interest (Hall et al, 2011). The authors discuss their experiences and results of informal research that led to their position that students' level of basic skills, ability to think critically, and ethical commitment are major factors in determining the success and continued interest of science majors.IntroductionIn 2008, 31 percent of U.S. bachelor's degrees were awarded in science and engineering fields, compared to 61 percent in Japan and 51 percent in China (National Math + Science Initiative, 2013). In 2009, 28% of high school freshman declared interest in science, technology, engineering, and mathematic (STEM) careers, but only 12% were still interested as senior students (NSF.gov, 2013). In 2011, a startling 55% of high school graduates were not ready for college-level math, and 69% were not ready for college-level science classes (NMS, 2013). The result is that 38% of college freshmen who declared as STEM majors do not graduate with a STEM degree (NMS, 2013).National efforts to address the absence of STEM graduates have focused on funding, increasing participation of minorities and women, new curriculum, scienceteacher training, and increased federal involvement (Forbes, 2012; NSF.org, 2012; PC AST, 2010). However, these efforts do not address the fundamental causes of failure of potential science majors that we have seen in our classrooms. In more than 5 years of working with more than 1000 students in community-college and university-class settings, we observed the deciding factor for success in science classes was whether the student possessed fundamental writing, math, and critical-thinking skills and an ethical commitment to persevere in a difficult course of study. We decided to explore these observations in detail by examining perceptions of students in introductory and advanced level science courses. Results for both populations were consistent with the thesis that interest alone was not the deciding factor for student success in science classes.Research MethodologyOur informal research centered on two populations of students: 140 communitycollege students in six introductory biology-for-majors courses, and 60 university students in upper-level biology courses, including Entomology, Invertebrate Zoology, Microbiology, and Environmental Issues and Ethics. The upper-level courses were a mixture of on-ground and online classes. The same instructor taught both course levels, providing consistent grading criteria across the groups.Most introductory students reported that they had graduated from area high schools or been home-schooled (2%) in the past 2 to 3 years. About 5% reported they had been out of school for some time. We observed the student population was predominantly white non-Hispanic, approximately 15% Latino, and 2% other minorities, including Asians and African Americans. These demographics were consistent with enrollments in other sections of this course in the department and the surrounding area. In 2012, the average income within a 20-mile radius of the college was $78,668 and, within a 5-mile radius, $96,160 (The Woodlands Corporation, 2013). Entrance requirements to the college are an SAT of 1070 with a 500 Verbal/Critical Reading and 500 math score (LSCS, n.d.). No college-level math or writing classes are required for enrollment in this introductory biology course for majors.Unfortunately, despite emphasis on constructive activities and varied facilitation methods, the success rate for the introductory course averages 50%. This is comparable to statistics for the Biology Department for this course for approximately 2000 students over the past 5 years (Lone Star College-Montgomery, 2013)Because the college does not offer upper-level biology courses, we used a second population of students from a university at which we also taught. …