Planning and Implementation Issues of Large-Scale Transit Modernization Plan: Case of Transantiago, Chile

Darío Hidalgo, Pierre Graftieaux

Transportation Research Board 87th Annual MeetingTransportation Research Board · 2008 · 10 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

This case study explores the planning and implementation of the Transantiago system from a learning perspective. Transantiago is the most ambitious transport modernization plan in a large developing city implemented in the last decade. The plan includes three main components, improvement of bus services citywide, expansion of the Metro system, and integration of all transit services in the city. The system was planned over a 6 year period, and implementation of the bus reorganization happened in a single process citywide in February 2007. Initial quality of service and coverage was very low and resulted in user dissatisfaction and even riots. Services gradually improved over the initial weeks but quality remained low. A comprehensive plan to improve services is underway, and final outcomes are not known yet. The case study, based on interviews, site visits and review of available material, provides a synthesis of the Santiago context, project components and development, dilemmas and barriers faced, design and implementation choices, initial results and contingency measures adopted. Conclusions include a list of lessons learnt –things done well, things that perhaps should have been done differently, critical positive enablers and critical barriers. Three elements emerge as critical causes of the initial operational problems: large scale reorganization was too difficult to manage; insufficient infrastructure support for high capacity operations (lack of bus lanes and integration facilities); and a trunk-feeder system design that greatly reduced bus system costs and emissions, but affected service delivery (walking and waiting times increased, bus occupation was unacceptable). Some recommendations for system improvement are provided.