WOULD YOU ALLOW YOUR ACCOUNTANT TO PERFORM SURGERY? IMPLICATIONS FOR EDUCATION OF PRIMARY TEACHERS

Lionel Pereira‐Mendoza

2002 · 14 citations · 1 references

Concepts

Abstract

The approach to this paper will be different from that usually presented at conferences. Rather than reporting on research, a specific curriculum, activities, or any of the multitude of other topics that often form the basis of a contribution, this paper focuses on some questions associated with statistical knowledge and asks the reader to think about the questions with a view to possibly setting a focus for research in the future; time and interest will determine if this is viable. Given this approach there is no attempt to include a review of the current literature in the area. In an article by Rothstein (2001) in The New York Times titled Statistics, a Tool for Life, Is Getting Short Shrift he argues that present programmes leave too little room for statistics. While he illustrates examples of statistics being used in the classroom the title and introduction to his article imply that there is insufficient statistics integrated into the curriculum. It would not be difficult to find articles that support statistical education as part of the curriculum. Most curriculum documents suggest that statistics be an integral part of the curriculum. The Curriculum and evaluation standards for school mathematics (National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1989) and A national statement on mathematics for Australian schools (Australian Education Council, 1991) are just two examples. Therefore, the issue facing statistics educators is not one of convincing educational organisations that statistics should be included in the curriculum, but issues associated with implementation. There is a large amount of literature on misconceptions in statistics and this is not reviewed here. Suffice it to say that there is considerable evidence that people at all levels, from primary school to adults, have misconceptions associated with statistical concepts. These misconceptions develop based on experiences both inside and outside the classroom. They develop even when students or adults have had no formal exposure to statistics in the curriculum. There are also a large number of books of activities for students designed to develop statistical concepts. There are computer programmes to help represent data, analyse data and simulate statistical situations. Textbooks have activities within the programmes designed to help students develop statistical ideas. So, although statistical education is a relatively new discipline, there is a body of knowledge that should help inform educational practice. However, there is limited knowledge of teachers' statistical knowledge and, in particular, what the knowledge is that primary teachers should have.

References

1