THE EFFECTS OF INNOVATIVE PEDESTRIAN SIGNS AT UNSIGNALIZED LOCATIONS: A TALE OF THREE TREATMENTS

Hainan Huang, Charles V. Zegeer, Richard B Nassi, B W Fairfax

Rosa P: A digital library for transportation research (United States Department of Transportation) · 2000 · 19 citations · 5 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Advisory and regulatory signs at crosswalks are intended to improve visibility and encourage motorists to yield, but alone they cannot guarantee compliance and must be paired with education, enforcement, and broader pedestrian-friendly design. The study evaluates three pedestrian safety devices—a Seattle overhead sign, New York/Portland safety cones, and a Tucson pedestrian‑activated overhead sign—to assess their effectiveness. The devices were installed and observed under diverse traffic and roadway conditions at the four sites. The Seattle overhead sign and New York cones increased motorists stopping for pedestrians, the Tucson sign increased yielding, and both Seattle and Tucson signs reduced pedestrians needing to run or hesitate, though none affected crossing rates.

Abstract

A variety of advisory and regulatory signs are used in conjunction with marked crosswalks to improve their visibility and increase the likelihood that motorists will yield to pedestrians. This paper evaluates three such devices: (1) an overhead sign in Seattle, Washington; (2) pedestrian safety cones (with the message, STATE LAW- YIELD TO PEDESTRIANS IN IN YOUR HALF OF THE ROAD) in New York State and Portland, Oregon; and (3) pedestrian-activated STOP FOR PEDESTRIAN IN CROSSWALK overhead signs in Tucson, Arizona. The signs were used under different traffic and roadway conditions. The New York cones and Seattle signs were effective in increasing the number of pedestrians who had the benefit of motorists stopping for them. At one location in Tucson, the overhead sign resulted in increased motorists yielding to pedestrians. The signs in Seattle and Tucson were effective in reducing the number of pedestrians who had to run, hesitate, or abort their crossing. None of the treatments had a clear effect on whether people crossed in the crosswalk. These devices by themselves cannot ensure that motorists will slow down and yield to pedestrians. It is essential to use these devices together with education and enforcement. Traffic engineers can use other measures as well, including designing friendlier pedestrian environments at the outset.

References

5