EducationTeacher EducationTeachingCritical TheoryGenocide StudiesPsychology Of ReligionHolocaust StudiesReflective Practice
Research & Practice, established early in 2001, features educational research that is directly relevant to the work of classroom teachers. Here, I invited Simone Schweber to examine teaching and learning about the Holocaust in light of alternative approaches, current politics, and popular culture. --Walter C. Parker, Research and Practice Editor, University of Washington, Seattle. In the 15 years that I have been teaching about the Holocaust, I have seen dramatic shifts in my students' attitudes and orientations towards learning about it. I recall that, years ago, my students approached the subject with a kind of inbred reverence, a seriousness and cautiousness that bordered on nervousness. They handled the topic gingerly, as if it could shatter. As evidence of that impression, I remember that I once planned to write an article railing against Holocaust sacralization--the idea that the Holocaust had become so sacred that it could only be talked about in hushed tones or with prayerful appropriateness. While I believed (and still do) that human atrocities deserve reverential responses, I feared then that the perceived sanctity of the Holocaust would stand in the way of its history being learned, really investigated, questioned, challenged and understood. Reverence, after all, is the enemy of inquiry. As further evidence of what might be called Holocaust-awe, I used to take Holocaust survivors to high schools in the San Francisco Bay Area. After the survivors would speak, I generally had to prod the students in the audience to ask You don't need to be shy, I used to say. These survivors have lived through more than answering your questions. Usually that was all that was needed to open the floodgate of queries. At the time, I was struck by the kinds of questions the students asked and by the sheer volume of questions; in hindsight, I am struck by the pause that preceded my prompts. I find that my students now tend to approach the Holocaust without that pause, without a default position of veneration. Holocaust is, for them, interesting but not awesome. I teach a college-level course on the Holocaust, wherein I have students in small groups lead a part of each class session. This past semester, one group of students led a Jeopardy game show to review information. student leaders tossed out mini-Snickers bars to reward their peers for right answers. Thus, in response to the 100-point answer, The name of the gas used to asphyxiate victims at Auschwitz, the two teams vied to be the first to ask, What is Zyklon B? juxtapositions were excruciating to me--the game show, the candy, and Auschwitz; worse than a bad joke, the combination seemed to me an obvious example of Holocaust trivialization, and I felt embarrassed to have it occurring in my classroom. And yet I also take responsibility for the activity. I had full knowledge of the students' plan, having ok'd it before allowing them to take the classroom stage. Moreover, I played along, consciously hiding my reactions as the activity unfolded so as not to quell my students' enthusiasm. I had decided that having students participate in such an activity and then fully debriefing their reactions would be more educative than quashing the plan outright; it was a classic ends-vs.-means trade-off calculation. Whether or not that was the right decision for my college-level students, and, more importantly, whether that would be the right decision in a high school classroom is not my point here: that the students would choose such a format is. I can't remember students making similar choices in the past. In the lengthy debriefing discussion, one of the students in the class mentioned that she was concurrently enrolled in a course on slavery and that she couldn't imagine the same activity occurring there. Where I once worried that the sanctification of the Holocaust stifled learning, I now worry that trivialization of the Holocaust impedes its understanding. …